9 ms·
Raster CRT Typography According to DEC
- edejong 8y agoSimilar project is cool-retro-term [1] although I think the defaults are a little over the top. [1] https://github.com/Swordfish90/cool-retro-term https://github.com/Swordfish90/cool-retro-term
- com2kid 8y agoI love cool-retro-term! I'd say the defaults are way over the top and probably hurt the projects adoption. Once I turned everything down, it has become the most readable modern terminal I've ever used!
- reaperducer 8y agocool-retro-term is my go-to terminal program for quick projects that don't need multiple panes. It freaks out the IT guys and our workspace consultants, which is a bonus. The only downside is that on macOS it crashes on quit. But since I'm quitting it anyway, no harm done.
- pushpop 8y agoWhy would cool-retro-term “freak out” IT professionals any more than a typical terminal emulator? Does “freak out” have some additional definition I’m unaware of? Personally I found cool-retro-term lacked support for a few ANSI escape sequences I needed for tmux to work quite how I liked which prevented me using it as my daily $TERM. I’m sure with a bit of effort I could have gotten it working but it was an effort not work making when there’s literally dozens of other ${TERM}s I could use and the only thing in favour of cool-retro-term is novelty. I do really like how cool-retro-term is an expansion of the acronym CRT. Clever project naming.
- reaperducer 8y agoWhy would cool-retro-term “freak out” IT professionals any more than a typical terminal emulator? Because a typical terminal emulator doesn't make the brand new monitor they just installed look like it's broken.
- pushpop 8y agoCool-retro-term doesn’t make a brand new monitor look like it’s broken. The effect of CRT isn’t even remotely what an LCD looks like when it fails. So I’m guessing when you say “IT professionals freak out” what you actually mean is “idiot desktop support engineers who think anyone who uses the command line are ‘l33t h4xx0rz’”. In which case they’d have a hernia if they saw the kind of workspace a typical non-poser runs.
- reaperducer 8y agoSo I’m guessing when you say “IT professionals freak out” what you actually mean is “idiot desktop support engineers who think anyone who uses the command line are ‘l33t h4xx0rz’”. You guessed wrong, since they're used to seeing me use iTerm all over my other monitors.
- pushpop 8y agoThat doesn’t prove my statement wrong. By the way, smooth move using an alternative account to circumvent the HN rule disallowing negative voting on replies. However I suggest next time you do this, you vary your timings a little. You make it obvious when every time my karma goes down is seconds after you comment.
- dang 8y agoWe just had to warn you about personal attacks a few days ago. If you continue to cross into incivility on HN, we're going to end up having to ban you. Could you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and fix this? Your comment also broke the guideline that asks you not to complain about votes. If you think you see abuse on HN, email us at hn@ycombinator.com instead. I looked at the data on your comments upthread and found no evidence of abuse. Everyone who voted was a long-established user.
- Keyframe 8y agoFantastic. My favourite terminal I worked on was the amber-colored vt320 hooked to a sun box and sometimes to an sgi. There was something special to it, even 'back in the day'.
- drudru11 8y agoTruth - the only problem with those old terminals was the keyboard. They tended to not have the control key or ESC key (DEC terminals) in a nice spot.
- Vogtinator 8y agoThere's a really interesting video about character generation on HP 264x series terminals: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QikO0WOAGWI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QikO0WOAGWI
- blattimwind 8y agoThat's nothing! Tektronix did vector fonts in the 60s using analogue ROMs.
- abainbridge 8y agoThat's nothing, the Jaquet-Droz family were producing glyphs from mechanical analogue storage in ~1770. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bY_wfKVjuJM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bY_wfKVjuJM
- pushpop 8y agoThat’s nothing, the Egyptians were writing glyphs to solid state analogue storage two thousand years before that. /s
- masswerk 8y agoAlso, see the use of a metal plate as a binary storage device for fonts used for the print on punch cards with the IBM key punches: https://www.masswerk.at/misc/card-punch-typography/ https://www.masswerk.at/misc/card-punch-typography/
- masswerk 8y agoHighly recommended! As are all these videos by Marc Verdiell.
- avian 8y agoInteresting post. From my work on 1980s micros that used CRT TVs for display, the phosphor response described here seems to be a bit oversimplified. In my purely subjective experience, rise time seems to be shorter than fall time - pixels will usually be visibly blurred on the trailing (right) edge, but sharper on the leading (left) edge. Another thing I noticed is that a longer horizontal row of pixels will leave a longer decay on the trailing edge than a single pixel. For example, the Ts will usually have their horizontal line visibly stretched on the trailing edge, even when the vertical line seemed sharp. Of course, purpose-built terminals might have used different phosphors than cheap TVs of the time. It might also have to do with video amp bandwidth, or something else electrical.
- jepler 8y agoWithout disagreeing with you, the diagrams from the linked page are pretty much reproductions of the ones from an official VT100 technical manual, https://vt100.net/docs/vt100-tm/ https://vt100.net/docs/vt100-tm/ It appears to me that the rise/fall graphs are just graphs of ideal RC networks, while the whole true CRT system will have lots of other factors such as inductance going on. When it comes to comparing what you might recall of CRT TVs and 80s micros to what a dedicated monochrome CRT would show, well, the dedicated CRT was much better and sharper, particularly if your color display technology involved a "composite" system like NTSC or PAL, where horizontal luminance (Y) bandwidth was SEVERELY limited to "make room for" the color information (I/Q). To get an idea of how much Composite video encoding degraded picture information, take a look at modern videos of "RGB-modded" classic consoles such as https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kpdpAxzjmA8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kpdpAxzjmA8 -- As far as I understand from the video explanation, both signals are video-captured, so this is not a "CRT effect", it's a "composite video effect" that makes the right-side image so smeared. There's also the palette difference, but that's more a matter of preference.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoWhat does the long decay times of forbidden transition lines have to do with analogue circuits?
- 8y ago
- jhallenworld 8y agoWe need the VT52 experience: relay clicks as you type.
- DonHopkins 8y agoMy favorite VT52 experience was at a science fiction convention with Doug Humphrey (DIGEX). In the middle of a party in a hotel room, DIGEX announced: "OK, it's time to go down to the garage and bringing up all the VT52's from my car!" Trusting Doug unconditionally, several of us volunteered to help. After we hauled a bunch of VT52's from the parking garage, through the hotel lobby, up the elevator, and back to the room, and set them down, Doug opened up one of the cases and announced: "The great thing about VT52's is that if you take the printer module out, there's just enough room for a 6 pack of Guinness Stout bottles inside!" https://vt100.net/docs/vt52-mm/chapter7.html https://vt100.net/docs/vt52-mm/chapter7.html https://vt100.net/docs/vt52-mm/figure7-2.html https://vt100.net/docs/vt52-mm/figure7-2.html
- ch_123 8y agoSome of IBM's mainframe terminals used a solenoid which would hit the side of the keyboard's case to indicate that a key-press was successfuly registered. This was in addition to the well documented clicking noise of IBM's keyboard switches.
- dfox 8y agoIIRC original 3270 keyboard had solenoid that physically prevented user from pressing any key when the terminal was busy and would not be able to register the key press.
- ch_123 8y agoThe solenoid on the one which I have (a 3278 keyboard) is separate to the keys. It is true that the solenoid will not operate when the terminal is unable to accept any key press, but it does not impede the operation of the keys themselves. To the best of my knowledge, the only IBM keyboards that could flat out prevent the keys from being pressed were ones based on the Selectric typewriter mechanism, such as the 2741
- notevenodd 8y agoIs the HTML5 "workbench" VT100/220 emulation available to try? (Didn't see a link to it)
- cat199 8y agothis is great! I'm a regular user of the glasstty font + the 'tritty'[1] utility which emulates serial line I/O to create the 'true unix terminal' experience. Looking forward to the next post! ps: improved smeary-220 font would be great :b .. [1] https://github.com/sjmulder/trickle https://github.com/sjmulder/trickle
- dfox 8y agoI'm not sure that all the smearing and blur is historically accurate for vt220. I still have Wyse WY-150 (IIRC) on my desk and while it has somewhat poor contrast (which seems to be mainly caused by worn out contrast pot, I gotta fix that someday), it has exceptionally crisp display. I remember the same "crispness" feeling from various amber phosphor MDA monitors.
- cat199 8y agogood point - I actually do have a 320 and the topics discussed in the article seem to jive with my experience with it.. but yes, it is very crisp - i think the point of the 'fuzzing' details discussed here is that they actually help the overall clarity (e.g. a 'dithering' sort of effect)
- bepvte 8y agoThis is great! Id love if this expertise was added to the cool-retro-term project.
- geuszb 8y agoExcellent research. I wonder who the artist is who drew the typeface and whether they realized at the time that it would have such significance that somebody would still be studying their work so many decades later
- 13of40 8y agoReminds me a bit of a weekend project I did a few years back: When I was about 6, my dad went out and bought what would be the family computer for half a decade, a TI-99/4a. The thing that stuck in my craw was that even though Apple and Commodore had mastered the lowercase Latin font, the lowercase letters on the TI were just tiny uppercase ones. So flash forward 25 years or so, and I'd downloaded a TI-99 emulator to play with, and decided to see if I could put an Apple II font on it. It was relatively easy to find the font in the ROM, and I found a donor font through Google. Kludged them together, and it worked beautifully. Lowercase letters on a TI-99! No idea WTF they were thinking with the original font.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI don't know either, however TI at the time also produced the "Silent 700" terminal series and it had the same font (all essentially upper case characters just some larger and some smaller. Perhaps it was an early example of the DRY mantra being applied incorrectly.
- theoh 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_caps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_caps
- theoh 8y agoThat was an unobjectionable comment, so I guess the downvotes are a stimulus to try to get me to write more. The Wikipedia page for the TI-99 mentions the "small capitals" but does not link to the page I linked to. So some people, at least, who read that page won't get the reference to the typographic tradition (if that's what it is). A larger issue is the idea that, by choosing a small caps style for their font, TI were acting inexplicably or irrationally. It is worrying but not surprising that the HN crowd finds it disturbing when a company makes a creative decision that doesn't have a clear business case behind it, while being completely innocuous, and which potentially could have helped to differentiate their products. It's the typical negative engineer stereotype coming through: "No imagination or creativity allowed, except if it's to solve a specific problem".
- ChickeNES 8y agoI need to find/buy an eeprom and programmer for my VT102, the character ROMs are failing and the text is totally garbled
- burfog 8y agoDEC Terminal Modern, fitting the old character shapes but having smooth outlines, is rather nice. It's almost like the new Chicago font, which Apple remade as a vector font that would produce the original bitmaps if rendered at the original size. I'd like to see that for the "fixed" font used as the xterm default. I got addicted to this font, but pixels are getting smaller and my eyes are getting worse.
- int_19h 8y agoOn an unrelated note, I wish somebody made a modern portable and low-power hardware terminal. Something with eInk, or maybe even reflective LCD, like those old "electronic organizers", but with a full-size screen. If it can do serial and serial-over-USB, that can come in handy with headless boxes, RPi etc.
- reaperducer 8y agoUntil that happens, Prompt for iOS by Panic Software out of Portland is very useful. I've used it on my iPhone in emergencies for years, and recently put it on an iPad and it really shines.
- reaperducer 8y agoIt's interesting that DEC did horizontal pixel stretching because individual dots would be too precise to be seen because of phosphor latency. The Commodore 64 had a similar problem with single-pixel latency, which is why the vertical portions of its character ROM are all two pixels wide. Otherwise, the character would be too blurry to be read comfortably on televisions of the era. I used to love making my own C-64 fonts pixel by pixel and comparing how they looked on a Panasonic portable TV versus my Commodore CM-141 monitor.