5 ms·
Why get so defensive? PG was merely stating a fact.
by olalonde 16y ago
Why get so defensive? PG was merely stating a fact.
- jacques_chester 16y agoWhy is it that 90% of the stories we hear involving Australia and technology are about stupid moves by the government? Is there something unique about Australia? This can be read as implying that Australians at-large are responsible. This isn't really true, it's an anomaly of our voting system (proportional representation in the Senate on a per-state basis) that sometimes leads to bad policy. So, for example, the retarded-policy bandwagon got rolling when Senator Harradine from Tasmania held the balance of power. He was able to block bills in the Senate and he used that power to get a lot of what he wanted, including bulk pork for Tasmania and some stupid internet policies. In the current Senate one of the cross-benchers (who can sometimes affect the outcome of votes, depending on what the Greens and other cross-benchers do) is Senator Fielding, a member of a speaking-in-tongues, happy-clappy christian party. One of their pet peeves is pornography, they think it makes god most displeased. Hence the government has been dangling the filtering stuff for years to help secure his vote. Technology-wise the current big argument is about a "National Broadband Network" a AU$50 billion (or $35 billion, depending on how you count) project to tear up Australia's copper network and replace it with fibre. To every home in the country. In US terms that's approximately like a $630 billion project (ie ~4.3% of GDP).
- hartror 16y ago... tear up Australia's copper network and replace it with fibre. To every home in the country. In US terms that's approximately like a $630 billion project. This deserves front billing. It will make us the envy of the western world when it comes to IT infrastructure and will hopefully drive a lot of innovation. We are doing this at a time when the rest of the world bar China (and thanks to China) is dealing with a crippling budget problem. It isn't controversial so it doesn't hit the front page of (and I don't say this to be inflammatory) American centric sites/blogs/media. There are many sexy IT stories that appear in local media all the time, but don't get covered simply because of where the mainstream blogs focus themselves. I have read similar complaints from non-silicon valley types.
- jacques_chester 16y ago> It isn't controversial so it doesn't hit the front page of (and I don't say this to be inflammatory) American centric sites/blogs/media It is highly controversial. I run a blog network including the "Terrible Trio" of Ozblog politics -- http://catallaxyfiles.com/ http://catallaxyfiles.com/, http://clubtroppo.com.au/ http://clubtroppo.com.au/ and http://larvatusprodeo.net/ http://larvatusprodeo.net/ -- and they spend a lot of time arguing the pros and cons. The posters on Larvatus Prodeo are generally bullish on the NBN, the posters on Catallaxy Files are quite anti-NBN. While I personally don't think that there can be any sensible technical argument made about the supremacy of FTTH for performance, the technical argument is not the key issue. It's about the cost-benefit tradeoffs, which aren't being seriously explored. Remember, this is the single largest infrastructure project in Australian history -- bigger in adjusted dollars than the Snowy Mountains Scheme -- it deserves some serious scrutiny on principle.
- robryan 16y agoYeah the real question is if this will deliver enough benefit to justify the costs, it's mostly sold to the public as improving medical services and businesses in rural areas. To look at it from the point of view of Melbourne though, if willing to pay for it we can already get 100mpbs net, something I'm sure will be available to everyone who can get cable currently before the NBN is done. It's worrying that they are avoiding releasing any type of business plan or cost benefit analysis. Also it was strange that the plan was out for a long time before they mentioned anything about the fact that the network would be able to deliver far more than 100mbps over time to the home. Makes me think many in the government didn't really understand what they are actually rolling out.
- hartror 16y agoI mean controversial on the world stage. And I would be happy with it being debated, pity the opposition is too busy trying to scuttle the government to actually provide a cohesive argument and analysis.
- jacques_chester 16y ago
- vorg 16y ago> it's an anomaly of our voting system (proportional representation in the Senate on a per-state basis) that sometimes leads to bad policy. The unusual aspect of Australia's voting system causing such bad policy is compulsory voting, rather than proportional representation. The people who wouldn't bother voting in other democracies need to toddle down to the booth in Australia to avoid a fine, resulting in a higher percentage of those unclued in tech matters being voted in. (Also explains why such things don't happen in NZ:)
- jacques_chester 16y ago> The unusual aspect of Australia's voting system causing such bad policy is compulsory voting, rather than proportional representation. I disagree. Compulsory voting is a net benefit, because it drives the parties to focus on the median voter (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hotellings_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hotellings_law). In voluntary systems, only motivated electors will turn out. How do you motivate people to vote? Not with discussion, but with emotion. Consider: US politics is marked by a startling mix of soaring rhetoric and ruthless negativity. Why? Because the goal is to get your own voters to turn out and to make the other guy's voters say "We give up, they all suck!" Australian politics might be a bit country-bumpkin in its tone and content, but it tends to focus on boring service-delivery issues rather than Grand Visions. Reform in stages is the general paradigm of Australian politics -- you have to carry that median voter with you. We do have the key advantage that bills to do with appropriation must deal only with appropriation (s 54). This makes it much harder for horse-trading to occur. Likewise, Australian-style party discipline is the strongest in the world and pretty much precludes sideline deal-making (for good and ill). As Murray Rothbard observed, minor technical details of process can have surprising practical consequences.