4 ms·
I don't think I've ever seen anyone cherry-pick various points from other posts without attribution before. Anything wrong with responding in the the thread i
by ghshephard 16y ago
I don't think I've ever seen anyone cherry-pick various points from other posts without attribution before. Anything wrong with responding in the the thread instead of constantly updating your post with other people's (including mine) comments?
Editing a post is typically for the purpose of fixing typos, making your (own) thoughts more concise or clear.
It's not for the wholesale amalgamation of other people's posts, as useful a function as you think you might be serving.
Let your original post stand on its own merit, or don't post it.
- wmf 16y agoHe's at the top of the thread, so those other comments will appear to be duplicates of his post. :-/
- ghshephard 16y agoAgreed. I recognized " This is probably the first case, though, of a cable-company ISP becoming large enough to extract transit fees from a big international carrier. " as being _your_ comment. The thing is - I learned that from _you_. So I'd kind of like to remember who I can trust to provide useful insight into these topics.
- tc 16y agoThis was simply a case of simultaneous editing. I saw your comments only after writing the substance of my updates (and in the case of wmf's comments, only because of this meta-point). I don't want anyone to think that your comments were copied from mine, though, so I'm sorry if it might otherwise appear that way. I've operated an ISP, and I'm deeply familiar with the issues involved here. I posted my main comment quickly and updated it as I thought more deeply about the press release. To my mind, a legitimate use of the editing feature is to improve a comment upon reflection. Again, I want it to be clear on the thread that I'm comfortable that your (and wmf's) comments weren't copied from mine, but neither is your accusation fair. I expect that we've all simply worked in or around the same industry and have seen similar things.