2 ms·
I agree with every point you've made in this thread, but bilbo0s has a good point about the optics. The vast majority of the voters do not understand economics
by nostrademons 8y ago
I agree with every point you've made in this thread, but bilbo0s has a good point about the optics. The vast majority of the voters do not understand economics, do not think systemically about "the greater good", and wouldn't follow an argument as abstract as "Most companies think their secrets are worth more than their competitors, but the only ones who are correct about that are giants like Google, who have every reason to push for trade-secret and non-compete agreements that restrict your labor freedoms and hamper your ability to get a better wage." There's a bunch of leaps of logic here that I believe and you believe because we understand competitive bargaining and have worked for Google, but which are completely foreign to someone who takes the first job they can get because they need money right now.
The fight for the 13th amendment was framed as "Slavery is evil. If you support slavery, you are evil too." That's the kind of moral argumentation that's simple enough that it can get voter support. There was a lot of economic jockeying going on and fights between new vs. entrenched interests going on in the Civil War, but all of that was hidden from the voters and largely written out of the histories. "Google spies on you" is an effective way to convince people to vote against Google's interests; "Google is commoditizing their complements and restricting their ability to make contracts to better their bargaining position" is gibberish to the average voter.
It's an unfortunate fact of life that nearly all good decisions are made for the wrong reasons. Sometimes I wish everybody could just understand markets and systems and vote according to their enlightened best interest - but they don't, and much of the fucked-upedness of the world comes from that.