3 ms·
Something I don't understand about induction charging: why is it even necessary if the device and charger are still expected to be in flat contact with one anot
by derefr 8y ago
Something I don't understand about induction charging: why is it even necessary if the device and charger are still expected to be in flat contact with one another (with at most a few millimeters of separation)?
Is the point just for arbitrary positionability on a flat charging surface?
If so, I feel like there are simpler ways to solve that, just with clever solid-state connector design.
Imagine a BGA processor that could be arbitrarily aligned into a BGA socket (not only rotated, but placed anywhere onto a BGA array larger than the CPU), and would continue working. That's possible, no? It doesn't exist, but it's possible. You could have the motherboard look for known sense pins on the processor by putting its own BGA pins into a sense mode; and then, having found which pins the processor is aligned to, it could "hook up" the rest of the pins appropriately. Any pins the CPU isn't touching would remain powered down or in a low-voltage sense mode, where they're safe to touch.
Well, if you can imagine that, then just reduce the number of pads on the device side from hundreds to two, while keeping all the pads on the socket side. But lose the "socket" part.
Imagine a charger that's just a big flat matrix of tiny copper pads, where each copper pad is actually four quadrants: two for sense, one for power, one for ground. The power and ground are normally powered down.
If you have a device (a phone, say) with two large flat charging pads on the back, and you lay it onto the BGA matrix—then the phone's pads will activate (a number of!) the charger's sense pads; the charger will have an "image" of which pins to power, and discretize that image into two clusters (like discretizing touch-points on a digitizer); and then one cluster of activated sense-pins will have their sibling power pins activated; and the other cluster will have their sibling ground pins activated.
Other than the copper being exposed to the elements, I don't see why this isn't workable.
(And before you say "my phone is in a case"—your case would just need a pair of pass-through conductor pads.)
- dkokelley 8y agoI wirelessly charge my iPhone through its case.
- rconti 8y agoHell, I charge my X through a Quad Lock case which is about as thick as you can get (it has a bulge on the back to handle the connection to the Quad Lock mounting devices). It doesn't work with everything, but it works with my cheapo Qi charger and my Nomad charger in my Tesla. I'm sure it charges more slowly than with no case, but it does what I need.
- astrea 8y agoWould you get sufficient contact for a solid current? What happens when you spill your coffee on the pad?
- ryanmcbride 8y agoI've always felt it was unnecessary too. A company I worked for a few years ago spent thousands to install wireless charging pads directly into the tables in every meeting room (4 floors worth of rooms). This was before any iphones had wireless charging though, so they also had these wireless charging adapters that plugged into iphones so that they could use them. That means that to charge your phone, you had to plug it in, but then leave it in a specific place in the table, making it so you can't really use it. It was the absolute worst of both worlds. They could have saved a ton of money by just having some cables attached to the table, but instead they wanted to use the hip cool technology before it was practical.
- redfern314 8y agoSome Starbucks did this for a while as well, provided adapters for USB micro / Lightning and had chargers at the center of every table. Not sure if they still do.
- efrafa 8y agoI saw wireless charging on tables in Starbucks in SF.
- OkGoDoIt 8y agoThat company also had like 10 video dongles/adapters in every conference room, including ancient 30-pin connectors, but no USB-C which was the only thing most employee laptops supported. Yay technology!
- ryanmcbride 8y agoHi Roger!
- jdietrich 8y agoIt has been tried in commercial products, but it's harder than it looks. Pogo pin type contacts don't have a lot of current capacity and there are some fairly serious issues with surface contamination and corrosion. The layout is easy, the electronics are easy, but the metallurgy of the contacts is an unsolved problem.
- lightedman 8y ago"but the metallurgy of the contacts is an unsolved problem" Solved for decades. Gold-plated stops corrosion and resists contamination of most any sort.
- hinkley 8y agoIn the late 90's there was a company trying to make a contact charger. I can't even remember what it was called now, but the gist was the device would have a couple pins, the charger a bunch of pin pads, and on detecting a device it would negotiate voltage and power level (like USB-C does now) and feed power to those pins.
- ip26 8y agoI had a phone w/ Qi for a couple years. It was finicky, requiring I develop the habit of aligning the phone on the charger. But once I got used to it, it was subtly very nice. No fiddling with cables at all. Nothing to wear out. Pick the phone up and go. It feels a little like a technology of ten or twenty years from now that is not technically necessary but will be nice & convenient. Think of WiFi compared to Ethernet. Right now we can see the future & taste it just a little, but we haven't quite got there yet.
- misterprime 8y agoBut what about USING the device while it's charging? You have to keep it flat on the charger. The plug in cable still has merit. Lemme know when we construct additional pylons and can charge things remotely (without cancer).
- ThatPlayer 8y agoThat's why it depends on your use case and lifestyle. But if you're sitting at a desk for hours, with a wireless charger it becomes second nature to just put your phone on the charger when you sit down and take it out of your pocket. So when you do pick it up again, it's fully charged and good to go. Yes, if you're a hardcore user who is on the phone for hours at a time, or are always moving out and about, then this isn't for you. As an analogy it's like slow charging an electric car at home. If I'm using 100 miles a day, then I'd have to visit a faster charging station at some point. But if I do not drive more than 20 miles a day, I have the convenience of being able to just charge it at home without going out of my way to a charging station.