6 ms·
> Sorry, can I just interrupt you there for a second? Just let me be clear: You’re saying that there is no rabbit hole effect on YouTube? > I’m trying to descr
by minimaxir 8y ago
> Sorry, can I just interrupt you there for a second? Just let me be clear: You’re saying that there is no rabbit hole effect on YouTube?
> I’m trying to describe to you the nature of the problem. So what I’m saying is that when a video is watched, you will see a number of videos that are then recommended. Some of those videos might have the perception of skewing in one direction or, you know, call it more extreme. There are other videos that skew in the opposite direction.
I assisted with data research on YouTube recommended videos (https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-youtubes-recommendation-rabbithole https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-y...), and this claim is misleading at best. There may be some videos that aren't extreme, but that doesn't matter if they are a) in the extreme minority and/or b) appear very far down in the queue of 20+ recommended videos when users typically either do "Up Next" or look at/action only the top few recommendations.
This isn't a "both sides" issue.
- nailer 8y agoThe Buzzfeed article quotes the SPLC, a partisan organisation that has labelled anti-FGM compaigners and Muslim reform groups as 'hate' groups (and only admitted the mistake under threat of legal action). https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-southern-poverty-law-center-has-lost-all-credibility/2018/06/21/22ab7d60-756d-11e8-9780-b1dd6a09b549_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-southern-poverty...
- ceejayoz 8y agoIf "fucked up majorly once" means you should be disregarded, Marc Thiessen of "torture is legal and effective" fame should go on your disregard list too.
- nailer 8y agoThere's two examples in the comment you're replying to, and you can find more in less time it took you to write that reply.
- manfredo 8y agoI don't think this is a fair summary of what the Product Chief is saying. When people talk about the YouTube rabbit hole, they're talking about watching video A, which links to B, to C, etc. until they reach content considered extreme. This is simplistic, but say all videos are on a 1-10 integer scale in terms of politics. YouTube always recommends 80% videos that are on the same value as the currently viewed video and 10% are one value higher and 10% are on one value lower. It doesn't push anyone in either direction. Randomly clicking on recommended videos will randomly move you up or down (and usually not move at all). But, no matter where you begin, you can always reach either end in 4 clicks - cue people talking about the YouTube rabbit hole. But hey, maybe it's not enough to merely prefer content that isn't extreme, what if we wanted to actively push people to the center? We could recommend 80% videos that are one value higher or lower towards the center spectrum (or the same is the viewed video is at 5 or 6), and 10% videos that are at the same value, and 10% towards one value away from the center. Randomly clicking on videos _will_ bring most viewers to the center in this system. But we can still reach the extremes in just 4 clicks. This is why complaining that users can go down a rabbit hole feels disingenuous to me. They always will be _able_ to do so - unless YouTube never recommends videos that aren't more centrist than the video being viewed. I suppose YouTube could just ban all videos that are at 1 and 10 in our spectrum, but that's basically just calling for censorship. And not to mention, 2 and 9 will just become the new definition of extreme. Edit: many of the comment lead me to think that I haven't made what is and isn't in scope of my comment clear. Allow me to point out two things in particular. 1. YouTube already does prohibit hate speech. How well it enforces its rules is a valid point of discussion, but not what I'm talking about here. I'm pointing out that the ability to get to the extremes of what _is_ allowed on the platform through recommendations should not in and of itself be a point of concern. 2. I'm also aware that sometimes the recommendation are very messed up in context of the current video - e.g. shock videos getting recommended to kids. But this is more about trolls deliberately gaming the recommendation algorithm, which I see as a distinct issue from the alleged rabbit hole pattern of recommendations.
- strangeloops85 8y agoThe alternative is that Youtube could choose NOT to recommend videos for large categories of videos, particularly those related to kids or other categories (for example, Rohingya-related videos in Myanmar in the current time period). You need not censor the videos, however you can choose to make their discovery less easy. There's no law that says they have to recommend videos. There is however sufficient evidence at this time around the rabbit-hole effect causing real-world harm. This isn't 2005. It's about time Youtube, and social media properties adopt the medical principle: "first, do no harm". Perhaps they will do this willingly, but somehow I doubt it. To wit: https://www.bellingcat.com/news/americas/2018/10/11/memes-infowars-75-fascist-activists-red-pilled/ https://www.bellingcat.com/news/americas/2018/10/11/memes-in...
- Adverblessly 8y agoI think that the claim you quoted is actually the less interesting claim in the article, the more interesting one is this: > ...It’s equally — depending on a user’s behavior — likely that you could have started on a more extreme video and actually moved in the other direction. > That’s what our research showed when we were looking at this more closely.. Now this is also a bit of a weasely claim. First because of "depending on user's behaviour" which isn't very clear (but for now I'll give the benefit of the doubt and assume they are trying to say "unless the user is actively seeking radical content"). Second because this claim could be true and YT would still be radicalizing (i.e. it could go 1->3, 3->2, 2->4, 4->3, 3->5, 5->4 in terms of extremeism giving a gradual slope towards radical while still maintaing that you are equally likely to navigate to more extreme content as you are to navigate to less extreme content). OTOH, if I understand the article you linked to correctly, all it says it that if you keep clicking "Up Next" you'll eventually get from mainstream content to extreme content, which doesn't invalidate the above YT claim if their research shows that users aren't actually doing that. Given that you assisted with that research maybe you could make it more clear what you tested and how it shows the "rabbit hole" effect?
- ehsankia 8y agoHonestly both of these are pretty easy claims to check. Not by manually looking and choosing recommended videos, but by following a random walk. If it is true that it all drags you into extreme videos, then if you take a random walk from any video, choosing recommendations at random, you would always end up down the hole in extreme videos. In a lot of these experiments though, people explicitly pick the more extreme of the recommendations repeatedly, which of course will lead you down the rabbit hole.
- kettlecorn 8y agoI have an unlisted video with about 15 views that when viewed in an incognito tab constantly recommends stuff like "Ben Shapiro owns liberal professor", alongside gun videos. I just did an experiment where I clicked one of these and clicked "next" a bunch going through their recommended videos. It immediately dove into alt-right stuff, and eventually led to videos of antifa protestors getting beaten up. This is normal on YouTube.
- opportune 8y agoI wonder how much of this is due to sponsorship. Aren't Ben Shapiro, PragerU, etc. billionaire-funded outreach programs? Can you pay Youtube to give your videos higher positioning in recommendation lists without their higher positions being explicitly labeled as "sponsored"?
- derp_dee_derp 8y agoNo, they are not billionaire funded. It is more likely to be a result of PragerU their lawsuit against youtube and YouTube adjusting their algorithm to give them a bit of a boost
- opportune 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PragerU#Funding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PragerU#Funding I'm not sure if Ben Shapiro is being directly funded but it looks like PragerU is mostly funded either directly by billionairs or by think tanks (which are often also funded by billionaires but I don't have time to dig into all of the different ones mentioned here)
- nailer 8y agoAlt right as in you found videos advocating for a white ethno state on youtube? Because that's the opposite of Ben Shapiro. Antifa are pretty explicitly ('by any means necessary', carrying baseball bats, beating people up) a violent group, people can and do enjoy seeing others retaliate.