3 ms·
Read the press release carefully: "“On November 19, 2010, Comcast informed Level 3 that, for the first time, it will demand a recurring fee from Level 3 to tra
by ghshephard 16y ago
Read the press release carefully:
"“On November 19, 2010, Comcast informed Level 3 that, for the first time, it will demand a recurring fee from Level 3 to transmit Internet online movies and other content to Comcast’s customers who request such content."
...and other content.
I'd like to know the entire story here. Is Comcast demanding that Level3 Pay a fee to deliver online movies, or is Comcast demanding peering fees. One of those is content neutral, the other is not.
Note - as I read it, Comcast is demanding peering fees from Level 3. Big Whoop.
I'm fine with Comcast demanding money from inbound-feeds to transit their network, and shutting them off if they don't pay it. That's why any sane content provider multi-homes . Think about the position Netflix put L3 in by announcing an "exclusive" CDN deal with L3. Comcasts negotiating position with L3 got a whole lot better.
This is not unusual on the internet - think about how often cogent gets de-peered because it's unwilling to pay peering fees. I've had a ton of colleagues get blackholed because they made the mistake of single-homing through cogent. Ironically, L3 depeered from Cogent a few years ago... So, what's good for the goose...
For a taste of how this type of negotiating constantly is going on in the background, see: http://www.renesys.com/tech/presentations/pdf/nanog43-peeringwars.pdf http://www.renesys.com/tech/presentations/pdf/nanog43-peerin...
Net-Net: Always Multi-home through at least a couple Tier 1 providers, so when one of them gets depeered, your customers can still communicate with you. Be wary of exclusive transit deals.
Anybody with some actual insight care to comment on what's really going on here?
- wmf 16y agoWhile peering disputes have happened throughout Internet history, it is unusual to see an eyeball ISP trying to charge a tier 1. Usually the money flows the opposite direction.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoHow many internet backbone providers are also content delivery networks (other than Google)?
- wmf 16y agoNow, almost all of them: http://www.renesys.com/blog/2010/10/internet-transit-sales-2005-10.shtml http://www.renesys.com/blog/2010/10/internet-transit-sales-2... I wouldn't really consider Google a "backbone provider" since they don't sell transit; they're more of an "extremely ginormous end site".
- Terretta 16y agoYou hit the nail on the head. It makes it incredibly difficult to compete as a CDN when your upstream backbones start selling their "free" bandwidth as a CDN service that competes with yours.
- trotsky 16y agoI think your comment is right on the money. The devil is undoubtedly in the details here. We know netflix just switched away from akamai for video cdn to l3. Aside from scale, it's easy to guess one of the major reasons was price - akamai is one of the highest cost providers and L3 has been aggressively bidding on work. We also know that akamai has way more POPs or at least caching locations (2000+ is the pr) and is very well positioned to locally deliver on comcast. L3 video CDN in contrast is more in the dozen or two POP range, and several of those may not yet be up to the weight of netflix traffic. If comcast is going to have to handle a ton more national traffic themselves because netflix is saving money by switching to L3 it only makes sense for comcast to try to offset those costs by charging for transit. What if I started CheapoStreamCo and started undercutting everyone in the business, but the only place I was on net was NYIIX. Think I'd be getting settlement free deals? Hell no.