4 ms·
The east of Ukraine voted for independence by 83%. So much for historically part of Russia! Many of the people voting for Russia in Crime were, er, Russian citi
by simonh 8y ago
The east of Ukraine voted for independence by 83%. So much for historically part of Russia! Many of the people voting for Russia in Crime were, er, Russian citizens working there. That's not an excuse for annexation. I happen to have some sympathy for Russia claims on Crimea for historical reasons, but annexation is many steps to far and what they've done to the Donbas and sealing off the Sea of Azov coast is utterly inexcusable.
I just don't accept that the US fomented anything in Ukraine. The people on the streets were Ukrianian citizens. Legitimate native protesters are routinely painted as foreign agents, but that doesn't make it the case.
There is no real reason for Ukrain and Russia to be at odds like this. Ukrainians have done nothing whatever to deserve the shoddy, dishonest knives in the back Russia has been dishing out to them. Ordinary Russians should be ashamed and humiliated by the way their government is ruthlessly betraying Ukrain and bullying ordinary Ukrainians at every turn. All they wanted was to function as an independent state and have friendly relations with the rest of Europe, but this was too much for Putin to stomach. What kind of example would that set for Russians?
Ukraine now has an active, boisterous and unruly democracy just as it should. That's a sign of health, compared to the sham opposition groups that always vote with the government and suspiciously overwhelming approval ratings you commonly get under oppressive regimes.
- senderista 8y agoMaybe this could change your mind? https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-ukraine-tape/leaked-audio-reveals-embarrassing-u-s-exchange-on-ukraine-eu-idUSBREA1601G20140207 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-ukraine-tape/leaked-a...
- simonh 8y agoNot really, no. People talk like that about their own and foreign nations politics all the time. Of course the American ambassador to Ukraine has strong opinions about politics in Ukraine. It's their job. What is being alleged, or at least vaguely suggested, is America causing a coup that would not have otherwise happened. That's simply, obviously not what occurred in Ukraine and anyway they've had many free and open elections since. America and the EU was exerting diplomatic pressure in exactly the same ways as Russia (except for poisoning Ukrainian politicians with Dioxin), none of which justifies military action.
- scottlocklin 8y agoThe "boisterous democracy" in Ukraine is presently stage managed by the US. For the love of god, Nuland-Kagan was caught by Russian spooks picking who was going to run what, like an imperial gauleiter. Yes, the white shirt bros in the West (who I deeply sympathize with, speaking of deep sympathies) acted as cannon fodder for our little project, but that doesn't mean its some spontaneous anything; it's a bloody imperial project, just like the attempts to remove Maduro in Venezuela. FWIIW I have business interests in Ukraine and know some of these people. It's a US satrapy from top to bottom. I don't think the Russians are innocent snowflakes, and I'd sure as hell rather live in the US than Russia, but it's super obvious what their grievances are, and that the US continuing to push NATO closer and closer to Moscow, and our various ham handed attempts to influence their political system is hugely dangerous.
- simonh 8y agoFrankly, I'm currently for as aggressive and restrictive a containment policy against Russia as possible. We've seen what Obama's 'reset' did - it created the diplomatic space for Russia to maul Ukraine. Giving Russia any slack whatsoever is a terrible mistake every time, they always use it to make more trouble. Just ask Georgia.
- scottlocklin 8y agoWell, I disagree with this view. I do not want to risk nuclear war with Russia over ... Latvia. Let alone Georgia (who shelled Russian troops -presumably you forgot about this part; also the part about how Russia left Georgia, because it's not really expansionist the way you seem to think it is). Or Ukraine. I mean, cool heavy metal records, and I like khachapuri as much as the next guy; it isn't something I care about enough to risk living in radioactive cinders. I do not see the US as world policeman, and do not trust the scumbags running the place to do a good job of it even if I did think that was a good idea. Since you bring up Georgia; how do you explain how our dude in Georgia, Saakashvili, showed up running a big chunk of Ukraine for a while? Does that not seem shady and "the US running Ukraine like a satrapy" to you?
- 8y ago