3 ms·
I am not talking about these specific pilots about which I know nothing. But not every single commercial pilot is passionate about his job. For some it is just
by cm2187 8y ago
I am not talking about these specific pilots about which I know nothing. But not every single commercial pilot is passionate about his job. For some it is just a day job and until they are asked to do a particular training, may not even be aware that MCAS even exists.
Think professional developers (granted the bar is infinitely lower). You would assume no one would introduce a SQL injection vulnerability in new code given all we know and all that happened. Well...
Also some commercial pilot on HN provided another element of answer. When you are in an emergency situation, you don't have the time to sit back and think, you revert to experience, muscle memory and training. Even if it may have crossed these guys mind that it was the same problem than Lion air, they may not necessarily know the procedure to fix it while trying to keep the plane from crashing at the same time.
Just speculating.
- VBprogrammer 8y agoThat would be a huge failing on behalf of the airline. There was an emergency airworthiness directive which should have brought this to the attention to all pilots of these aircraft even if they somehow missed all of the other coverage.
- chopin 8y agoBut this directive said "handle like a trim runaway". However MCAS may present itself differently from a trim runaway when failing. Furthermore a failing sensor may activate the stick shaker and the last thing a pilot is trained to do is pull up in such a situation. So you might get: - unreliable airspeed warning - stick shaker (=stall is imminent) So you don't know your airspeed (otherwise you can conclude you're safe for your current pitch and vertical speed) and a stall warning. The last thing you do is to look for horizontal trim.
- VBprogrammer 8y agoThe full list of potential indications is included in the AD. It also describes the operation of the trim system under MCAS control. You can see them in the Lion Air preliminary report linked above. Pilots are trained to deal with partial panel situations. The mantra is pitch + power = performance. In VMC this should be well within the capibilities of a normal pilot, put the nose on the horizon and set something like 65% power.