3 ms·
Ask HN: How to structure the funding for my company?
I'm starting to organize a round of funding for my company, so I can raise more money to finish up and launch the technology I've been working on for over a year. But since I don't have much professional experience with raising money, I have a question.
It seems to me that the coolest way to structure an investment is like this: come in with an amount of $ that you will need in order to be sure you can take the company to the next level, and then negotiate how much % you are willing to give away. Let's say it's $200,000 for 20% of the company. Then take the deal with the investors you think are the best fit, but structure it as follows:
The $200,000 is set aside for being used if your company needs it. That way everyone ensures the company won't fail for lack of money. But you withdraw the money in $10,000 increments. Each time you withdraw, you sign a note and that is when the investors get the corresponding % in your company. If you wind up using $40,000 and launch something that makes your company way more valuable, you can start shopping around for a much bigger valuation. Let's say by the time you have spent $50,000, you have found investors interested in doing a round at a 10 million dollar valuation. Then your first investors at this point own 5% stake in your company, but that 5% just became 10x more valuable (as did your shares as a founder). Now you do the same thing at the second round of funding, etc.
This way, it's a fair deal for everyone involved and the incentives properly align with what's good for the company. The entrepreneur will not want to just waste the money they are given, and in fact will actively try to grow the company's value. This seems like a good deal for the investors, too. In fact, if I was investing $200,000 into a company, this is exactly how I'd want to structure it -- I'd start to feel uneasy if the company started spending the last of the $200,000 without another deal in place yet at a much higher valuation. Giving the entrepreneur the incentive to constantly grow the value of the company (and as a result, give away less equity) seems to promote runaway hits, which is what VCs try to fund all the time.
Investors in previous rounds would be invited to participate in later rounds. But there won't be any "back-room deals": once someone is willing to invest in your company at a 10mil valuation, someone cant go "just give us another 2% at the old valuation".
What do you think? If there are any seasoned investors reading this, could you please give me a piece of your wisdom? I'm just speaking out of intuition here.
- answerly 16y agoIt sounds like you are asking the investor to take all the risk of a standard investment, but with potentially less upside. Seems like a tough sell.
- EGreg 16y agoI'd argue that there is more upside in the long run. If you stop taking the investor's money it's either because your company has become profitable, or because you have been able to do a round of funding at a higher valuation. Either of these means that the investor has started to get a return on their money, which is way better than sinking their entire investment into a company that fails. Your investor can even do a partial exit at the next round, reimbursing themselves for 100% of their original investment, and still have shares left over. Shouldn't the investor incentivize the entrepreneur to do this?
- camz 16y agoIt would have to depend on the investor. Honestly you have a founders bias, which is natural. This could be the case with an angel investor but definitely not acceptablefor vcs. Honestly, I'd think that angels wouldn't want the deal either. When people invest in a company, they generally want a significant amount of equity in the company. It's a long process to find suitable investments and if they don't make a significant investment then it wouldn't be worth their time. If I was the investor then I wouldn't accept your deal because what's the point if buying such a small percentage since I wouldn't have a board seat or any significant control or say in the company. Having a say is important to me because it allows me to protect my investment as well. Thus, for these reasons I believe that your deal is unrealistic for most general angels and vcs.
- EGreg 16y agoThat numbers I posted are just an illustration. I see what you're saying about being on the board, etc. and you're right, I haven't thought that part out ... this may be a deal that's better for "passive" investors, who don't want to really have to deal with control of the company. But ask yourself, though. If you invested $200,000 into a company, wouldn't you want that company to become profitable or raise a larger round before it ran out of money? Wouldn't you be nervous if it spent $180,000 and YOU were its only hope? On the flip side, often founders need only around $20-50k before launching something. If things don't go as planned, they may need as much as $100,000 due to unforeseen circumstances. Unless you can predict the future, a range would work better than a set amount. So I think it makes sense to set aside the maximum amount of that range, but have the option of raising the second round early, before using up the whole range. The reason that the founder has to explicitly draw money on the allotted amount, is to prevent "giving back the money to the investor" when they have found a better deal, which wouldn't be fair. But I think this scheme is fair to both parties. Why exploit the inefficiency of a founder to be unable to predict the future? Make your money on the actual rise in the company's value. Would you agree?
- imcqueen 16y agoIt's an interesting concept, but as an investor I would not want to allocate money without it officially being invested. In other words I'm on the line for a theoretical 200K, but I'm only putting 20K of it to work. The reason I wanted to invest, say 200K, is because I believe in your idea and I want in while it's cheap. I want to buy low. Nothing wrong with keeping this alternative in your back pocket in case any investors want to try it, but I would lead with a traditional approach.
- staunch 16y agoThis happens quite often. It's just done in multiple rounds: Seed (<=$100K) -> Angel (<=$1M) -> VC This is more comfortable for both sides I think. a) The investor knows how much equity he owns. b) The founders know how much runway they have.
- EGreg 16y agoExactly :) Cool.
- rms 16y agoConvertible debt!