3 ms·
I have had a couple instances of ventricular fibrillation. I have an implant which brings me back to life when that happens; I would be dead without it. However
by dheera 8y ago
I have had a couple instances of ventricular fibrillation. I have an implant which brings me back to life when that happens; I would be dead without it. However, I do go unconscious for a few seconds until I get shocked back to life.
Although my case is infrequent enough that it is not thought of as a risk by the medical community, for peace of mind what I would really like to have is a link between a watch of some sort and a car capable of self driving. Should I be driving when I go unconscious, all the car would need to do is automatically kick in autopilot mode while gradually slowing down, until a heart rhythm is detected again.
The risk is small, if you consider the percentage of time I'm behind the wheel, but it would be good for peace of mind. It would also be helpful for others who do not yet know they have a heart condition, or those who are having a stroke or epileptic attack while at the wheel. There are others with worse conditions than mine who are basically advised not to drive, so it would help them as well.
If falling asleep can be detected by any biological signals, that would also be a useful autopilot trigger while waking the driver up, for the general population.
Currently most cars require manually activating the autopilot mode; what I'm proposing is a vital sign monitor to automatically begin self-driving if the human is incapacitated.
If the human doesn't wake up within a half a minute or so, the car could also self-drive itself to a hospital. I think we're far enough with self-driving tech that that saved life would far outweigh the risks of the self-driving system having any issues en route.
- dreamcompiler 8y ago> the car could also self-drive itself to a hospital I think you're onto a good idea, except for the above quote. It would be a much better idea to have the car automatically pull over to the shoulder, stop, engage the flashers, and call 911. Paramedics can keep you alive en route to the hospital with drugs, cardioversion, and CPR. Your car cannot.
- microcolonel 8y agothey could meet half way maybe.
- killjoywashere 8y agoJust so people understand, in the present day, what you're proposing involves a $5M mission package with $200M worth of airborne combat control systems and related ground support. Oh, and then the "bring dead guy back to life" bit once they get the intercept. The idea that we're going to start vectoring ambulances to intercept self-driving cars carrying heart attack victims is pretty crazy awesome.
- drcross 8y agoTheres no reason with C2C communication coming online that cars will simply move out of the way if you put the car into emergency mode. Obviously we would build anti-abuse features into the system. Pushed out further, I don't mind if some rich guy wants me to pull over to get out of his way for a 50 dollar micropayment.
- ptaipale 8y agoSending ambulances to cars where a heart attack victim is detected is, however, a feasible use case. Where I live, in the order of 10 % of road casualties are actually casualties of heart attack or stroke; there is no actual road accident at all except that the car perhaps stops - but yes, the government still counts them as "road casualties" because that validates car and fuel taxes.
- dheera 8y agoPerhaps the best thing would be for it to meet the ambulance half-way or 1/3 way, to minimize time to reach paramedic care.
- tapland 8y agoThe problem is response time. If you are currently on the road it's probably faster to head to the hospital than to wait for an ambulance.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoWhich hospital is nearest? Which can be reached within the self-driving capabilities of the car? Which has Advanced Cardiac Life Support staff and equipment? Which is still open? Which is not already handling another cardiac emergency? Which route has the least traffic? Paramedics and EMTs can work these questions quickly and they have lights and sirens to get through traffic. Your car will probably google "hospitals" and (slowly) take you to the nearest one, which might be a closed methadone clinic. In most cities, an ambulance is going to get to your car much quicker than your car would get you to an appropriate hospital. A modern ACLS rescue unit is effectively a heart hospital on wheels. So calling 911 brings the hospital to you, without putting anybody else on the road in danger from your car's not-yet-quite-ready-for-unsupervised-operation autopilot software.
- tapland 8y agoVery location dependent for response times and traffic. Getting to any ER is better than nothing and the device is unlikely to differentiate cardiac arrest from a ton of other issues that might not need that cardiac team.
- JaumeGreen 8y agoSo what it is needed is that the car communicates with 911 and an automated system will tell it to wait for help, go to a destination where help will go to, or go to a help center (hospital or similar) where help will be waiting. It could even work if you are at home and have an emergency. Call 911 and if they decide you should go to a health center on your own it will send where to go to your car. Of course at first wait for help should be the default, but when automated driving improves, and the processing of emergencies improves too, an automated response system should be the norm for most of the time.
- 8y ago
- azinman2 8y agoPerhaps you shouldn’t be driving? Sounds really dangerous to me...
- dheera 8y agoObjectively speaking it's infrequent enough (only 3 times in my life so far) that it's statistically noise compared to the probability of an accident due to other reasons, including other drivers. There's actually a medical paper that calculates these probabilities, and the gist of it is that I should be okay to drive a small vehicle point-to-point for personal reasons but not be a professional driver that drives a large vehicle multiple hours per day every day. I'm also thought to be under control via medications now, and also am scheduled for an ablation procedure which may cure it altogether. The bad news about medications, and that procedure, is that it's hard to know whether it cured it, considering how infrequently they happen. I could go another 10 years without incident and then it happens again -- or I could go my entire life and it never happens -- nobody knows. So the best I can do at the moment is to just carry on with life. That said though, I would still feel emotionally safer if the car drove itself, or at least could detect such things. Not only for myself, but for the sake of those people who have incurable frequent instances of incapacitation -- they actually are not advised to never drive -- as well as the entire rest of the population that is over-stressed and under-slept. Also, I feel what has happened to me could happen to anyone. Doctors haven't been able to diagnose any particular cause, but I have been under extreme work stress over the years, and the connection between that and heart failure among other things is really not well understood. Extreme electrolyte loss is another way any otherwise normal person could go into ventricular fibrillation as well, and that's not something everyone is educated about. I bike most of the time, and drive only occasionally, by the way. If you look at that in isolation, yes, I'm more likely to die being incapacitated on a bike than in a car. But if you look at the problem holistically, biking is more likely to improve my cardiac condition over time via much needed exercise, as well as the reduction in stress by doing stuff I enjoy doing. For all we know, living a life of abstaining from everything could be far more likely to pile on stress that could potentially make things worse.
- heavenlyblue 8y ago>> I think we're far enough with self-driving tech that that saved life would far outweigh the risks of the self-driving system having any issues en route. What if the self-driving tech kills both you and someone else on the route?
- Kuinox 8y agoSeatbelt can already kill you. Statistically it save more life than it kill. The self driving tech of today is enough to do a controlled emergency stop that is statically better than an uncontrolled vehicle.