3 ms·
Wow, this feels pretty solid and snappy, at least on desktop (Firefox 67). The scrolling effect's a bit weird, but I'm sure that can be customized. I switched
by yellowapple 8y ago
Wow, this feels pretty solid and snappy, at least on desktop (Firefox 67). The scrolling effect's a bit weird, but I'm sure that can be customized. I switched off JS expecting everything to rapidly fall apart, but it actually works surprisingly well; the homepage on the demo site is broken (displays fine, but doesn't response to mouse events like scrolling and clicking; arrow keys work fine for scrolling), but the other tabs work significantly better than I'd ever expect a site this visually-complex to work without JS.
On mobile the demo site does feel weird (a taller-than-wide screen and a vertical tab bar don't exactly mix), but it's still plenty usable and snappy on Firefox for Android. The sample sites are much more normal in terms of mobile site UX.
A lot of people here seem to be bagging on it for silly reasons (like "I have to press the back button multiple times after clicking on multiple things!"; gee, turns out clicking on links adds entries to your browser history, who'da thunk?). Don't listen to them. You've done a fantastic job with this framework, and I look forward to using it for my own projects.
I will say that one thing I'd change is to provide the option of making it a little more opinionated/invasive. I shouldn't have to say <table class="n-table"> everywhere; I'd rather just say <table> and be done with it. I'm sure I could figure out how to customize this to add that opinionation/invasiveness, but it'd be nice if it was an (opt-in!) out-of-the-box option.
EDIT: In the spirit of "let's really break this thing", I fired up the Haiku Nightly VM I've got laying around and tried loading the homepage and some of the demo pages in both WebPositive (WebKit-based) and NetSurf (uses its own rendering engine). WebPositive handled everything like a champ (albeit with some severe loading lag on the homepage; the demo pages all loaded fine). NetSurf failed entirely on the homepage (shows the nav and nothing else, even after clicking on nav entries), but the demo pages work reasonably well (they're at least viewable, even if the proportions are wonky in a lot of places).
Either way, the fact that the framework itself works okay even on an obscure operating system running in a virtual machine with only 1024MB of RAM is delightfully impressive.
- rado 8y agoHi, I got important feedback on 1.0 here years ago and every comment is valuable. The opinionation topic is very tricky, I thought a lot about that and decided to go unopinionated for maximum compatibility. On the other hand some CMSs simply won't allow adding a table class so there should be an opinionated option or something. A major principle is CSS-only functionality, accessibility and stability (it probably has the only proper modal window on iPhone Safari). Happy to see you found it useful and I hope at least people will be inspired to give the open web a chance. Thanks.