4 ms·
Education has value. Degrees are merely a conveyance of an education. The educational institution is an indicator of the educational rigor. None of these are pe
by taylodl 8y ago
Education has value. Degrees are merely a conveyance of an education. The educational institution is an indicator of the educational rigor. None of these are perfect indicators.
If you're interviewing candidates and you have a candidate graduating from Stanford, one from MIT and one from Middle-of-Nowhere State - which candidates are you going to prefer? We can argue whether such preferential judgement is justified. Living near the East Coast I can tell you I've met my share of MIT grads who are idiots and Middle-of-Nowhere State grads who've been really good. Yet the perception persists. Why? Because of the handful of truly outstanding, even legendary, graduates the elite schools have had that Middle-of-Nowhere State hasn't. Those handful of exceptional graduates skew people's perception of reality for a really long time.
Who knows? Maybe this scandal will change people's perception of these elite schools but I doubt it.
- mrspeaker 8y agoSo it sounds like you're saying the real scam is pretending that degrees have value?
- snarf21 8y agoI'd phrase GP response as saying we attribute too much value on some degrees and not enough on others. They all have some (nominal?) value but we don't spend the time to figure it out and just shorthand it based on the "quality" of the school. The presumption is that these schools only let in the best so you can trust their stamp of approval but this scandal shows that is folly.
- hangonhn 8y agoIt can become a self-fullfilling prophecy: if most people believe that degrees have value, then the people who compete for those spots at "elite" colleges will go up, then the pool of high quality candidate goes up. Because the elite schools have the pick of the litter, the chances that their student body and thus their graduates will be successful goes up. This reinforces the perception that the degrees have value and the cycle repeats. I think an accident of history has started this cycle and it's going to endure for quite a while. It's akin to Silicon Valley: engineers think that being in SV helps them be successful and join the next rocketship. Startups get drawn to SV because they think SV is where the magic happens. Because the pool of talent and opportunities meet in SV, it reinforces the perception that SV is magic.
- craftinator 8y agoI think you hit on the way economists define "value"; value is derived from people believing something is valuable. Take gold or diamonds for example, which were highly valued before they even had industrial usages. Yes, both are pretty and are rare; however, there are many other equally pretty/rare things that weren't valued as highly. The only value they had was from perception, and that made the value real.
- saagarjha 8y agoThere's also the fact that a graduate from MIT is likely to have more opportunities and resources: a middle-of-nowhere state school is unlikely to have multiple professors who lead the field while an average MIT graduate might interact with several, and a student from MIT is more likely to have access to research and advanced classes by virtue of their university.
- sethhochberg 8y agoInternet discussions about universities seem to love to ignore this aspect of what makes elite institutions elite - sure, they're often old boys clubs, but those old boys fund endowments that can support specialty programs staffed by elite experts with elite lab facilities and guest speakers and all sorts of other opportunities beyond classroom learning. I'm not saying that you can't get a good or even great education at a community college or average state school - but I am saying that its silly to pretend that all university experiences are created equal and are just a way to consolidate class or whatever. What you do matters more than where you go, but an institution with better resources is going to have far more opportunity for its students to do meaningfully educational things. I'm going to take a resume that has some do-nothing degree from Central Midwest State U about as seriously as one that has a do-nothing degree from Stanford on it, but I would fully expect that your average Stanford resume might have a few more interesting line-items on it than the CMSU one based simply on having more opportunities available to them. (And for the record, I didn't attend a particularly prestigious school, and studied music in college despite working in tech now. I'm not exactly trying to defend my own background with this post).
- stevenjohns 8y agoThat’s one approach. Another approach is that you have a candidate that graduated from Stanford, one from MIT, and you have a candidate that doesn’t even have a degree from Middle-of-nowhere State but has 4 years full-time professional experience. I’m going to be more excited about the last candidate than the other two.
- kyrra 8y agoThere was actually an interesting article about this in WSJ this past weekend[0]. I believe it's based on her paper released a few months ago[1]. For most students, what you do while in college matters much more than where you go. [0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-right-way-to-choose-a-college-11553266896 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-right-way-to-choose-a-colle... [1] https://ed.stanford.edu/news/first-step-choosing-right-college-ignore-rankings-says-stanford-researcher https://ed.stanford.edu/news/first-step-choosing-right-colle...
- pedalpete 8y agoOne of the best engineers I ever met went to a school you never heard of. He couldn't afford to go to MIT. None of our team went to elite schools, we've all worked with elite individuals (also not from elite schools). I didn't even go to university, but through hard work, perseverance and a TON of luck, have been able to work my self up to some interesting places. I know when I'm hiring, I look more at where a person has worked than the school they have come from.
- whiddershins 8y agoWhen I was in high school I was told there’s not really any such thing as “can’t afford MIT” as in, if you get in, they will make sure you can pay for it through grants/loans/etc. Was that never true? Has that changed? Or by “can’t afford” do you mean “unwilling to take on debt” which is valid ... I’m just trying to understand that part of your story.
- NeutronStar 8y ago> The annual full price of an MIT education is $70,240. > As a result, last year the average total price paid by an MIT student receiving need-based aid was $23,000, which is less than the cost of attending the average public university as an in-state student. Overall, we awarded nearly $120 million in scholarships, and 72% of students graduated debt free. > Those who do borrow have debt at graduation considerably lower than the national average. Nationally, in 2017, graduates of four-year colleges who borrowed owed an average of $28,699 in loans. By comparison, members of the MIT Class of 2017 who took out loans graduated with an average debt of $19,819, way below the national average. Looks like MIT might be cheaper than the average university.
- rhino369 8y agoI'm not sure if it's still true, but that was a development that occurred in the mid-to-late 2000s. Before then financial aid was aimed at poor students. But if your family was middle class, you'd get virtually nothing (but loan options). I know several people who attend UIUC with me who got accepted to MIT, Stanford, etc, but their parents couldn't afford private school. But by the time my sister went to school, all the elite schools offered better terms.
- eblanshey 8y ago> Because of the handful of truly outstanding, even legendary, graduates the elite schools have had that Middle-of-Nowhere State hasn't. But I can equally say the same for the handful of truly outstanding, even legendary people who never even graduated from college. This is still one of those perpetuated beliefs that just because you spent 4+ years worth of time, effort, and money to get a degree you are more likely to be better than others. I think it's possible you'll have an easier time finding what you want if you look to the good colleges -- but only because the graduates who went there accepted the same belief that the employers do: that you need the degree to get a job. Chicken and the egg problem? Yeah, but I think it's slowly starting to change. It just takes enough young people to show the world that university is NOT needed, only the perseverance and love for what you do.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoYou're kind of ignoring the thesis of the article. This article is specifically NOT about hard schools (caltech, MIT) in fact it calls them out as counter-examples. This article is targeting prestigious, easy schools that do grade-inflation (e.g. Harvard). It is specifically accusing the easy-to-pass hard-to-get-in schools of being a mere status symbol, in turn the wider population of being silly for taking that symbol so seriously.
- ajcodez 8y agoIt's not on the university to stop, it's on the rest of the world to wake up.