5 ms·
He succesfully performed a complicated surgery for $10K that would cost $200K in the US. And India still can't afford to pay those prices. The problem is obvi
by jrochkind1 8y ago
He succesfully performed a complicated surgery for $10K that would cost $200K in the US.
And India still can't afford to pay those prices.
The problem is obviously not that THIS guy is not working efficiently. It's that the distribution of wealth under our planetary economic system is deeply unfair.
- barry-cotter 8y agoThe natural distribution of wealth, on the other hand, is eminently fair. Before agriculture everyone was poor. After the rise of agriculture almost everyone was poor but there were many more of them, and those who were “not poor” had no medicine worth the name, could not travel with anything resembling modern convenience and lived in the dark when the sun went down. Starting sometime between 1300 and 1800, depending on measurement the first sustained rise in living standards in human history began, because of capitalism. It’s how almost all other sustained rises in living standards have happened too. China’s first growth miracle in the 20th century happened because going from civil war to the Communist Party was an improvement but in India, China, Indonesia, Russia, moving to capitalism lead to a rise in living standards. Fairness would be nice but let’s try getting everyone out of poverty first.
- omegaworks 8y agoIt's kind of a relative quantity though, so the numbers might not necessarily be as comparable. The value of a dollar in India might be much higher. $1 is almost 70 indian rupees, and the distribution of rupees might be slightly more equitable among the population of India.
- jrochkind1 8y agoTrue, but it's the distribution of wealth _between_ the U.S. and India that I'm thinking of. They can't afford to give most of their population needed heart surgery even when they've made it 100x cheaper than it is here. Here health care is destroying us too, but _most_ (not all) people who need heart surgery still get it. Sometimes it destroys them financially (not saying health care works here either), but they get the surgery. And our economy does not crash. So far. India literally can't afford to give them the surgery.
- omegaworks 8y ago>India literally can't afford to give them the surgery. This is what's hard to conceptually grasp about nationalized healthcare. The concept of "a nation can't afford" does not make sense because a nation-state with control of its own currency can simply create and allocate the currency to serve this purpose. I'm not sure why this is not on the table.
- iguy 8y agoNo, I disagree. The money represents the real output of the economy. This can be moved around to some degree (switch a bicycle factory to making surgical tools, etc) but fundamentally only so much stuff is produced. Printing more money doesn't change this. Economic growth does, but not overnight. And figuring out how to do equivalent things with less input (whether it's model-Ts, or surgery) is an important part of that. To take an extreme example, every space-X launch costs $50 million. If I say that America could not afford to give everyone an orbital holiday, this is not a statement about fiat dollars. It's a statement about the enormous resources, and chiefly the labor of an enormous team of people (including all the suppliers, and their suppliers) required for each such trip.
- tomp 8y ago> The concept of "a nation can't afford" does not make sense Of course it makes sense. In any healthcare system (yeah, even pricate insurance) there are tradeoffs to be made, because the reality is that resources (hospitals, doctors, time, not necessarily just money) will always be finite. For example, having a breast scan every year might save more people than having it every 5 years, but at some point the marginal returns will be so small that it makes more sense to focus resources on other things.
- vidarh 8y agoBecause money is just a proxy for resources. Printing more money does not create more of everything else, so it drives inflation and effectively acts as a tax on all other economic activity. You can print more, but you need to be aware that what you are doing has that effect, and if you overdo it you'll cripple your economy just the same as if you increase tax rates too much.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sneakernets 8y agoI had a history professor tell me that if there was any kind of cultural/economic revolution in the US, it would be over health care. And that was during the worst of the HMO days. It's even worse now with these "HMO/PPO hybrid" systems, where instead of getting nothing, you get "something", then a massive hospital bill afterwards.
- thatoneuser 8y agoIdk if I'd agree that it's "unfair" because that implies there's some natural balance we've disrupted, when in reality wealth is largely the result of labor and ingenuity. If a group of people gets together and creates wealth for themselves and their offspring, is it unfair that they are wealthier than the rest of the population? That kind of thinking at some level is fundamentally unfair itself - if you go collect and store nuts for winter you're less likely to starve. If we say that it's unfair now that you have all these nuts and winter is coming, then how does one provide for one's self fairly? Wealth isn't distributed, it's created. I mean you can distribute after that but it would be theft. Nonetheless I hate that some people are just born into economic situations where they are severely less able to actuakize their potential, so I share your sentiment. I just don't like the word unfair as it seems to disregard accomplishment and to me it demonizes people who have succeeded.
- lemoncucumber 8y agoThe aspect of capitalism that's problematic to me is not that people can generate wealth through labor, it's that they can generate wealth through wealth. You can make far more money just by being rich and owning capital than you ever can by your own labor. You can own physical property that makes money like farmland, apartment buildings, natural resources, factories, etc. or you can be a shareholder in companies which make money. Either way, it's not really your labor that's making you richer, and that's the part that feels unfair about the whole system. A piece of anecdata to support my point: the richest families in Florence today are the same familes that were rich 700 years ago, too: https://www.vox.com/2016/5/18/11691818/barone-mocetti-florence https://www.vox.com/2016/5/18/11691818/barone-mocetti-floren...
- thatoneuser 8y agoI agree to some extent that wealth begetting wealth can be problematic, but in order to have the first bit of wealth someone has to create it. If you made the first hammer you'd be able to make more hammers much easier. You've effectively made the world wealthier by your work and invention and as a result it's fair that you get more than just the value of your hammer. Your claim about making more wealth from wealth than labor kinda skips over the parts about needing so much wealth and having to accumulate it.