4 ms·
> Tech firms in China typically expect their employees to work long hours to prove their dedication. > By the end of 2018, many tech companies were announcing
by AlexandrB 8y ago
> Tech firms in China typically expect their employees to work long hours to prove their dedication.
> By the end of 2018, many tech companies were announcing plans to cut benefits, bonuses and jobs as they hunkered down amid the country’s worst economic slowdown in nearly three decades.
> Yang is pondering what comes next. With more than 10 years of experience, he now holds a mid-level position at a top-tier internet company but has reached a career ceiling. He compares himself to a construction worker, who can earn good money due to high work intensity but can easily be replaced by younger, cheaper labour.
There's a lesson here. Anyone who asks you to be "dedicated" to their business or cause is looking to exploit you. When things get tough, they will not repay your dedication in-kind.
- chrisco255 8y agoI mean, I wouldn't go so far as to assume that the word "dedicated" automatically means exploitation and extrapolate that across the spectrum of organizations that are out there. That's quite a reach.
- AlexandrB 8y agoDedication almost always translates to "doing stuff you're not getting paid to do". How exploitative this is depends on context. If you're volunteering at the local community theatre, it's not really exploitative. You're there for your own reasons, probably doing something you like. However, if you're asked to be dedicated at your job in a multimillion dollar corporation what's probably happening is they're trying to save on labor costs. And they're doing it by keeping headcount lower than it otherwise needs to be to get the job done. This becomes really apparent when you consider contractors. Nobody ever screens contractors for "dedication". They find one whose rate and qualifications are acceptable and pay them for their time. Likewise with other professions like lawyers. It's weird how this has become normalized for many rank-and-file tech employees though.
- chrisco255 8y agoNo, it doesn't. The word dedicated just means that you're engaged with the problems that the business is trying to solve. You are always doing things for your own personal reasons. Whether volunteering or not. It's also true (besides the point about dedication), that certain jobs and certain missions DO require extraordinary hours. NASA required long hours for their Apollo engineers. It's unlikely they would have achieved what they did if they had engineers that worked 9-5 with an hour for lunch and multiple breaks throughout the day. Was this exploitation? No. Folks knew going in what they were trying to achieve had never been done before. People do screen contractors for dedication. For whatever job you're hiring for, you want someone dedicated to solving problems, overcoming obstacles, and executing effectively.
- jlarocco 8y agoHa! You don't have to look to China to see that. American companies have been playing that game for 40 years now.
- jcbrand 8y ago> He compares himself to a construction worker, who can earn good money due to high work intensity but can easily be replaced by younger, cheaper labour. The only solution I can think of (if you want to keep on programming and not make a career change), is to acquire skills in such a way that you cannot be easily replaced by younger cheaper labour. Easier said than done, but one way to do this IMO is to not go after the fads, but instead to pick less sexy but still useful and important technologies and to become an expert in those. Also, what's been a useful heuristic for me, is what Nassim Taleb calls the "Lindy" effect. The longer something has been in use, the longer you can expect it to be used. This applies especially to technology.
- bluedino 8y agoI wouldn't say that's always true. I've been at plenty of places that keep 'baggage' employees around because "They paid their dues", or "They were with us during the tough times", or "they've done a lot ffor this company" Usually the smaller the company, the more attachment there is to those employees. No matter how useless they are at the current time
- z2 8y agoMy guideline has been to love people, not institutions. Not through any fault of the institutions, but rather through physical reality, they can only be as dedicated to their members as a person can be to individual cells in their body.
- xiphias2 8y agoThis is one of the best metaphors I have heared for a long time :)
- kartan 8y ago> Anyone who asks you to be "dedicated" to their business or cause is looking to exploit you. When things get tough, they will not repay your dedication in-kind. If you give your time for free to a company. The company will assume that your time is worth nothing. And once the expectation is created, there is no gratefulness for doing it. The only thing that you will get is a bad looks if you stop giving your time for free because now it is expected.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoEasier said than done when you're only other option is toiling in a field.
- kartan 8y ago> Easier said than done when you're only other option is toiling in a field. Yes. There is times that developer do not have a real option to say no. But, it is good for junior developers to understand what they are agreeing to and what are the consequences. In the end businesses are going to ask for so much as legally is possible. If 15 hours/day where legalized, it is what people would get.
- jlokier 8y ago> If you give your time for free to a company. The company will assume that your time is worth nothing. And once the expectation is created, there is no gratefulness for doing it. The only thing that you will get is a bad looks if you stop giving your time for free because now it is expected. This happens in charity-sector voluntary organisations too. Having worked extensively for free (both in open source and community charity work), I found it becomes extremely draining when you really get to appreciate how people take your free time for granted, get angry if you don't give more and more to fulfil their unrealistic expectations, you can't find a way off the treadmill that doesn't get you into difficulties somehow, and there's not much support or meaningful help if you're having a rough time of it. It's one of those things that sounds theoretically obvious from a distance, but actually being in the thick of it is such a different and unexpected experience. It does lead to burnout as well as lasting trauma. Also, to what I call "weaponisation" of language making it harder to talk about such things. For example, "you seem like you're heading for burnout", from people saying it for office politics reasons (self promotion) rather than empathy, and who are often the chief causes of said burnout and trauma. I have seen people work 70 hour weeks in that situation for free, in addition to their day job they have to do to be paid, feeling more obligated to do the free work than the paid work when they clash, because of the pressures of expectations, and a bit of a "100 bosses 5 workers" problem in co-operative type social organisations.
- xiphias2 8y agoI think people on the west already know this. It seems like Chinese people have to learn it the hard way.