3 ms·
All governments, regardless of their nature, all civil societies and all bodies of law, from the hardest fascist dictatorships to the freest democracies, claim
by krapp 8y ago
All governments, regardless of their nature, all civil societies and all bodies of law, from the hardest fascist dictatorships to the freest democracies, claim legitimacy by and execute enforcement through a monopoly on violence.
Pretending the US is any different in this regard is silly.
- geggam 8y agogovt in the US does not have a monopoly on violence... they want you to think they do ;)
- krapp 8y agoI don't think you understand what the monopoly on violence actually is. It doesn't mean the government is the only agent capable of committing violence, rather, that the government determines what forms of violence, and under what circumstances, are legal, and that the enforcement of laws and contracts are always backed up by an implicit threat of violence through incarceration or worse. The Second Amendment being legal doctrine adopted by the government is an example of that monopoly being extended to the people - yet the same government that passed the Second Amendment also put down Shay's Rebellion. That's the monopoly on violence.
- geggam 8y agoYou do realize the constitution and the bill of rights do not grant rights but limit the governments ability to infringe on your natural law granted rights ? To summarize the govt is limited and the people are not. The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.