3 ms·
While management is definitely culpable, aviation is not like most software development shops in that legally speaking, your engineers do have final say. If the
by salawat 8y ago
While management is definitely culpable, aviation is not like most software development shops in that legally speaking, your engineers do have final say. If they don't sign, nothing ships. An engineer is expected to do more than acquiesce to management's demands. It is, in fact, an engineer's job to say "no" to any implementation plan that jeopardizes the public.
There is a case to be made whether it is reasonable to expect an engineer to branch their scrutiny beyond what small slice they are given, in which case there was a failure at a higher level to distribute appropriate units of work such that the entire thing was thoroughly vetted. The problem is, that is extremely difficult to prove in a court of law, and it is not uncommon for high level management to hide unethical practices behind indirect communication methods without committing them outright to paper.
Call me a romantic, but at some point, as a bunch of engineers on a project, you need to be able to fully grok and model the entirety of the system as a whole. It seems that level of integration would have brought these problems to light much faster, and without the bloodshed. I can't imagine that work not happening unless it was being actively discouraged. If one or several engineers had pushed back, or a manager been thinking more about product quality/safety rather than delivery/profit, that work may have been done, and we wouldn't be talking about this now.