4 ms·
>> Kingsnorth said this is because the words we use to describe our world shape our perception of it. That's the concept of Linguistic relativity, also known a
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> Kingsnorth said this is because the words we use to describe our world shape our perception of it.
That's the concept of Linguistic relativity, also known as the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity
The strong version says that language determines thought and that linguistic categories limit and determine cognitive categories.
The weak version says that linguistic categories and usage only influence thought and decisions.
My understanding is that this idea is controversial and in any case, difficult to demonstrate, because it's mostly impossible to know one's thoughts without asking them to put them into words, and also because language understanding is subjective and it's impossible to understand what someone is saying without placing it in the context of our knowledge and understanding of the world in the first place.
- BucketSort 8y agoMy subjective experience of flow states[1] makes me believe this is true. In these states thinking feels much less discrete (which is something language seems to impose) and more continuous. Any programmer knows what this feels like when you get into a serious coding session. You get to the point where all the principles of programming fade from your attention and focus more on how information is being shaped by your program (learning Haskell brought this to a new level for me). There have been times where I couldn't even explain what I had done in words, which gives me further evidence that flow is related to breaking down this linguistic imposition. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_(psychology)
- TomMarius 8y agoOur team has started using types-code to communicate, works well. We have unified basic interfaces and concepts, that helps.
- 234x1fchqaefn 8y agoThe strong version is hilariously easy to destroy: if you're cognitively limited to your language, then you cannot create new words, let alone new concepts. Since it is patently false that no new words or new concepts are created, by Modus Tollens, it is also false that you are cognitively limited to your language. The weak version seems true to me. I think it is absolutely the case that your language colors your thought.
- dmreedy 8y agoI'm not sure that argument is a complete route of the strong (or at least, stronger) hypothesis. The conscious creation of new words is often done using fusions or appropriations of existing words, per Lakoff's Metaphors. Over time, the meanings shift and expand, but it's not a raw, instantaneous act of creation, that, to your point, would seem to be impossible under Strong Sapir-Whorf. Now, we can, here and now, 'invent' a 'new' word from what we believe to be whole cloth. But it's hard to prove that that there's not some unconscious process similar to the above going on! That really all we're doing is finding the intersections of existing semantic distributions. Incidentally, my favorite SIGBOVIK paper: https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~tom7/papers/sigbovik2011tom7whatwords.pdf https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~tom7/papers/sigbovik2011tom7whatword...
- jfengel 8y agoI'm not sure that even the weak case is true: while it could be that language colors thought, it could as easily be the reverse. We may pick our languages to reflect the thoughts we have. Those thoughts are heavily influenced by culture, and language is a strong tool for communicating culture, but it's not the only one. Apes communicate culture by watching rather than speaking, and my cat learns that she's not supposed to go on the table even though she doesn't understand when I tell her. So while language and thought patterns may be correlated, the arrow of causation isn't necessarily one way. Experiments that show people thinking in certain grooves divided by language, but concluding that the latter causes the former may be putting the cart before the horse.
- arebours 8y ago> The strong version is hilariously easy to destroy: if you're cognitively limited to your language, then you cannot create new words, let alone new concepts. It depends on what's the thing you define a language. It might be that dictionary and grammar are only a kind of projection of a more blurry, hidden structure - a language "core". Think of how children sometimes invent new words and how these words immediately "click" with fluent speakers even if they mean shit. IANAL(inguist) so take it with a grain of salt.
- arebours 8y ago