4 ms·
Marx had a lot of ideas; some of them were probably good. Involving workers in the ownership of companies seems like a good idea even if Marx supported it. Mar
by roenxi 8y ago
Marx had a lot of ideas; some of them were probably good. Involving workers in the ownership of companies seems like a good idea even if Marx supported it.
Marxism as practiced in places like, eg, Russia fell down because they disrupted the ability of the market to send and receive accurate price signals and over time that led to catastrophically misallocated resources. Many of the people who want socialism seem to support disabling said price signals, because they are unfair, which is why socialism is so dangerous - those price signals are very important. However, as long as they face the same risk of bankruptcy as everyone else, workers co-ops with the ability for outsiders to invest are probably a superior model of ownership.
- coldtea 8y ago>Marx had a lot of ideas; some of them were probably good. Involving workers in the ownership of companies seems like a good idea even if Marx supported it. I'm not saying otherwise. In fact, a lot of Marx ideas were good. He also famously said "I'm not a marxist".
- Frost1x 8y agoAs implemented in the current US economy, those price signals are also suppressed through collusion, cronyism, and near monopolies so it's not an exclusive issue of socialism implementations. Many markets are stagnant and do not offer healthy competition. There's a fair share of markets that still offer healthy competition, but from my perspective, it seems like the end goal of market optimization almost inevitably leads to monopolization which always leads to stagnation. True competition and an informed/economically conscious consumer market are key requirements to this signaling process. We don't have a lot of either in many markets.
- RA_Fisher 8y agoOne of the great things about capitalism is that it has some redundancy and resiliency. Competition may also lead to new features (markets), etc. On the other hand, this is duplicative and wasteful. Contrast the duplication (redundancy) of the capitalist system to the one producer model of communism. Less duplication but less resiliency and less ability to find new features (market). I think when a market is young and returns are high that it makes sense for many producers. However as a market matures, we can shed some of the duplication and allocate it to other new markets. If the monopolist restricts quantity sold? Easy, it increases the tears for a new entrant. The system manages itself in this way (in reality no system at all, it's decentralized coordination).
- magduf 8y agoThe problem with this idea of "duplication" is that, in reality, it's never been shown that monopolies are actually highly efficient. Humans just aren't very good at being efficient when they aren't forced to, and competition does that. The places where we do have monopolies that work out OK are where there's heavy government regulation, and even there the results are never as good as an industry where there's highly competitive private industry; it's just that, for some things, having a regulated monopoly is better than the alternative: we see this for utilities, subways, etc. where competition doesn't really make any sense or just isn't feasible (you can't really have 5 different subway lines going between the same 2 points in a dense city). In reality, humans are frequently lazy, corrupt, incompetent, etc., and so in a market where there's healthy competition, the presence of competition provides a check against these problems, giving consumers an alternative when one player screws up too much. With a monopoly, there is no alternative, and no incentive to do better, unless it's being heavily controlled by the government which has to respond to voters.
- 49531 8y ago> Russia fell down because they disrupted the ability of the market to send and receive accurate price signals and over time that led to catastrophically misallocated resources. This is extremely ahistorical. The fall of the USSR was due to Gorbachev's decision to introduce "western" markets into Russia and Yeltsin's opportunism. Growth and stability weren't flagging in the Soviet Union until they attempted to privatize.
- ido 8y agoEconomic growth was actually even worse before glasnost: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_Soviet_Union#/media/File:Graph_of_Soviet_National_Income_Growth.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_Soviet_Union#/m...
- 49531 8y agoAnd if the US had been the one to capitulate to communism we'd be quoting stats about the lack of income growth of their workers in contrast to the wealthy. Viewing the health of a nation on the growth of their income isn't necessarily telling the story. Soviet inflation was almost unheard of save for hyperinflation shortly after the revolution, and hyper inflation after the collapse. Also as investment wasn't as much of a driving force since the economy wasn't private, so infinite growth isn't necessarily a good indicator of the state of things.
- maxxxxx 8y agoThey were slowly decaying like Cuba is doing now. Same for East Germany. There wasn’t much growth going on. Stability only in the sense of stagnation.