4 ms·
> If they did require a separate type rating, this would likely kill 737 sales Would it, though? I'm genuinely asking because I don't know how much all this c
by kelnos 8y ago
> If they did require a separate type rating, this would likely kill 737 sales
Would it, though? I'm genuinely asking because I don't know how much all this costs. Certainly certifying pilots for a new aircraft isn't free, and probably isn't cheap, but the MAX line promises significant savings in fuel cost. In the long run, would the latter outweigh the former?
- gsnedders 8y agoIt likely would; if you have a fleet full of 737s and the 737 MAX turns into a new type rating, there's a much weaker argument as why they must get the 737 MAX rather than an A320neo family aircraft, and that gives Airbus a big in-road with potential customers. That's not to say that Airbus would get all the sales (they won't!), but they then have a much easier time to selling to former 737 customers.
- adwww 8y ago^^ I just made the exact same comment, but this puts it clearer!
- isostatic 8y agoSo Boeing may have to reduce the price a little. C'est la vie. However ti's unlikely to cause major problems, presumably the tooling and spares for the non-max 737 are pretty similar to the 737. If you own a fleet of Boeing mid-range jets, why would you suddenly start to buy airbus?
- gsnedders 8y agoThat depends if the certification of the tooling and spares allows them to be used interchangeably between the pre-MAX and the MAX.
- robin_reala 8y agoOut of interest, why wouldn’t Airbus get those sales?
- icebraining 8y agoall those sales
- gsnedders 8y agoAnd notably, all the build slots for the A320neo family are sold for the next few years; I believe an order today won't be delivered till 2022 (and if you have other aircraft going off-lease, especially if some other airline is taking them on, you might not be able to wait). And you won't order today, because sales take time. If you have a delivery date prior to that for the 737 MAX, you may well just want to wait and hope everything gets rectified before your delivery. Boeing also have an incentive to shift their product, and with their negotiating position weakened will likely offer to sell their product for a lower price than they currently would to customers who already have 737s.
- magduf 8y ago>And notably, all the build slots for the A320neo family are sold for the next few years; I believe an order today won't be delivered till 2022 There's a simple solution for this: increase manufacturing capacity. How do you do this quickly? It's simple: there's a really huge airplane manufacturing plant in Washington, USA that may be up for sale soon...
- adwww 8y agoAirlines will all have their own long list of criteria to help decide which aircraft to buy. Removing common type will mean a few less points in a given airliners scoring system - it might tip the score to favour the Airbus for some, and for other airlines it might not even be a consideration.
- rootusrootus 8y agoWhy would they? It's not like Airbus planes haven't had their own fatal glitches. Heck, it hasn't even been all that long since they had their own version of an MCAS style failure which was only recoverable because it happened a lot farther from the ground.
- adwww 8y agoI expect it makes switching to an Airbus model more compelling - if you're going to have to retrain your crew, you might as well get the plane you want, not just the one you think will be easiest to train for. I have no idea if the equivalent Airbus (a320neo maybe?) is any better or worse than the 737Max, but losing the common type rating would be one less vote for the 737 max.
- dogra 8y agoThe wings of the A320 have more ground clearing than the 737 NG. Airbus could easily fit the larger and more efficient engines. Boeing had to move the engines slightly before the wings (or face an expensive complete redesign). The resulting different flight behavior would have required a new type rating (which is expensive). Instead software (cheap!) was used to correct for the different behavior. This is not an indication on other aspects of the A320 vs. the 737 MAX.
- gsnedders 8y agoAnd remember that on the Boeing 737 Classic and NG that the engine nacelle has been non-circular and been running with smaller fans than other aircraft with similar engines: engine size isn't a new problem with the MAX, it's been a problem since the move to high-bypass engines.
- ReptileMan 8y agoThe problem was not that the redisign was expensive - we are talking about trillion dollar market here but that it was slow - clean sheet = 10 years. Making an octopus by nailing four more legs to the old 737 5-6 years. I am fairly certain that if boing could have solved the timing issue by throwing money at it they woyld have done so.
- ams6110 8y agoI would suspect that training a 737 pilot on differences in the new MAX would still be far less involved than training them to understand an Airbus, which is a totally different philosophy in control systems and piloting.
- 8y ago
- 8draco8 8y agoDisclaimer: I'm not a pilot, I am just plane enthusiast. Type training for 737 starts at roughly $13k, 767 rating starts at $18k so I guess 737 MAX having more systems to go trough than 737 should cost somewhere in between if it would be separate type. Currently 737 MAX need just type differences training if pilot have already 737 rating, so it cost somewhere in the ball park of $2k to do that. All of those are prices available to pilots, so if pilot want to get the rating and pay it for himself. I assume that airlines would have some kind of discount.
- askvictor 8y agoI read recently the the 737max was specifically designed (and rushed out) as a response to American Airlines ordering Airbus. Boeing made the max a bit more efficient, and kept the type rating the same as selling points.
- ams6110 8y agoI would guess at the end of the day it wouldn't end up being a totally separate type rating. It would be additional training on the differences. But I think Boeing wanted to avoid the requirement even for that.
- bumby 8y agoI don't think it's just the personnel retraining. My understanding is that this decision helped keep the aircraft from being a "major" configuration change that would necessitate a more lengthy FAA certification process. Supposedly, a major air carrier gave Boeing a timeline deadline which may have influenced design decisions to avoid that longer certification. Of course the FAA may be partly culpable for delegating some of their oversight decisions to Boeing
- magduf 8y ago>Certainly certifying pilots for a new aircraft isn't free, and probably isn't cheap, but the MAX line promises significant savings in fuel cost. In the long run, would the latter outweigh the former? The savings in fuel cost isn't everything, because you're missing the fact that Boeing was competing directly against the Airbus 320neo, which likely offered the same fuel economy but without the extra training costs. Why bother buying a Boeing when you can get the Airbus for less? It seems pretty obvious to me that Boeing has been milking the 737 airframe for far too long, instead of proactively developing a replacement when they had time. Instead, they just stuck with what they had, and then when Airbus came up with their plane, Boeing tried to come up with something competitive on short notice using old junk they already had. They should have developed a successor to the 737 many years ago and moved to that, spreading the development and certification costs out, but they were short-sighted and cheap, and now it's going to cost them very dearly.
- tropo 8y agoThe engineers were busy with the 777 and 787.
- kelnos 8y agoSwitching from Boeing to Airbus would be more than just pilot and crew retraining, though, right? Maintenance and part sourcing would be significantly different as well. Obviously there are differences between 737 and 737 MAX there as well, but I can't imagine they'd be as significant. In addition, since the 737 and 737 MAX are very similar from a piloting standpoint, I would expect that getting type certified on a MAX when you already are certified on a vanilla 737 would be much easier and cheaper than type certifying on a completely different plane from another manufacturer.