4 ms·
today i first time saw the 737 MAX frontal view. Initially i thought that it was that typical funny plane-themed photoshop. I kid you not, it is the real thing
by trhway 8y ago
today i first time saw the 737 MAX frontal view. Initially i thought that it was that typical funny plane-themed photoshop. I kid you not, it is the real thing - https://i.stack.imgur.com/GFzcj.jpg https://i.stack.imgur.com/GFzcj.jpg
Just look at those nacelles. Deep breath. Look again. Take them in. Besides clearly visually screaming that this Frankenstein thing was quickly&cheaply slapped together and wasn't properly engineered and thus should just have never seen the light of the day, these nacelles obviously add more lift than normal symmetrical ones. So:
1. the engines placed more forward than pre-MAX 737 - that results in additional pitching up moment as the engines are below the centers of pressure, gravity, etc.
2. the engines are 2x higher-by-pass than pre-MAX 737 and thus the center of thrust is shifted even more forward and lower - as a result it adds even more of the pitching up
3. these asymmetrical nacelles generate more lift just due to the shape - and again due to the position of the engines that lift results in the additional pitching up moment.
Basically that thing just can't really fly steady straight, and looking at all this some people at Boeing decided that a bandaid software patch would just fix it. Sounds like it were the same people who did the "curl" fix in today Cisco story https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19508472 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19508472 :)
- ihuk 8y agoI will not comment on (1) and (2) but (3) is wrong. I don't think that's even a 737 MAX on the picture. 737 was originally designed to be low to the ground to make it easier for ground crew to "bulk" load i.e. just throw stuff into the cargo area. The reason why 737 could be so low to the ground was that they were using turbojet[1] engines. Turbojet engines are very slim compared to new turbofan engines used on later 737 generations. When they moved to turbofan engines which have bigger diameter they needed to move them higher up from the ground. So they moved the engines in front of the wings. To gain even more ground clearance they moved accessory gearbox and fuel pump from underneath the engine to the side. That's why engine appears flat on the bottom. Obviously the engine is still round because the fan is round but the lip is flattened. All this allowed Boing to fit more efficient and quieter engines to 737 without extending landing gear. The shape itself does not generate much aerodynamical lift if any. On the 737 MAX they actually extended the landing gear and it does not feature "flattened" engine shape any more. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratt_%26_Whitney_JT8D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratt_%26_Whitney_JT8D