4 ms·
What happened to Heather Heyer was also not speech. What happened to Clementa Pinckney and 8 other African-Americans at the Charleston church shooting was not s
by laughinghan 8y ago
What happened to Heather Heyer was also not speech. What happened to Clementa Pinckney and 8 other African-Americans at the Charleston church shooting was not speech. What happened at the Tree of Life Pittsburgh synagogue shooting was not speech.
Shouldn't the same argument apply to the videos that radicalized those murderers?
- joombaga 8y agoNo. Why should it?
- laughinghan 8y agoMy parent comment had said that conspiracy to recruit people to commit crimes is not an unreasonable basis for making it illegal to distribute recruitment videos for ISIS, because they are a criminal organization due to their violence, not their speech. That implies that that should also not be an unreasonable basis for making it illegal to distribute recruitment videos for violent white nationalist organizations. Does that answer your question?
- joombaga 8y agoYes, thank you for explaining. I misunderstood the context of your question.
- int_19h 8y agoIf you can prove that any particular video did so, sure, I don't see a problem with that.