2 ms·
"Do we really need to know a lot of this mundane stuff?" I guess this is opinion but I didn't think that the released information was mundane. "and one in whi
by chaostheory 16y ago
"Do we really need to know a lot of this mundane stuff?"
I guess this is opinion but I didn't think that the released information was mundane.
"and one in which classified documents are leaked all the time but no one even reads the public documents to begin with, I'd prefer to live in the former. Unforunately currently the US is the latter."
Actually imo the US is a country where "a lot of things are classified, but where most of the populace is too disinterested to read public documents or stay current on news." However, that doesn't mean that there isn't any value for educated, interested parties in having access to public documents.
Wikileaks is a recent phenomenom and not an age old one.
- krschultz 16y agoYou made the assertion that "democratic republics work better [with a lot of classified documents getting leaked]" I don't think you can just state that without justification. Anything juicy enough to be a revelation will probably also cause diplomatic problems for our country. Is that helping us? I think almost everyone in this country agrees we wouldn't want to see Iran or North Korea with nukes, we just disagree on what should be done about it. Diplomacy on those issues could well be more difficult now because of this leak. Why is that a good thing? What benefit has outweighed that cost? That now you know what our state department's negotiating plan is? I get why certain things should be leaked when it is necessary, but this seems to me to be one guy with sour grapes dumping reams of data for no clear reason and some tidbits of it being interesting. And what happens after X millions of pages are leaked when the one super important thing (ala the Nixon papers of today) are leaked and nobody cares? Has that made it a better place?
- chaostheory 16y agoWhat's the alternative? Being completely in the dark about everything? I admit that it's far from perfect, but the government is not transparent enough given their size and strength nor are main stream media outlets doing their job well enough. Maybe if the government was less pervasive and more hands off (i.e. taxes and so on) I would be less interested in their day to day affairs.