4 ms·
> They wouldn't do that, because there would be justified public outcry Where would the outcry happen? There aren't that many public platforms with any reach,
by BurningFrog 8y ago
> They wouldn't do that, because there would be justified public outcry
Where would the outcry happen?
There aren't that many public platforms with any reach, and they're all adopting similar policies.
In [blocked] no one can hear you scream!
- javajosh 8y agoYou have misused a slippery slope argument to turn the other position into a strawman. There are risks to this FB ban, but silencing outcry about the ban is not one of them. In practice, the distinction between banning a subject and banning a conversation about a subject ban, is easy to make. For example, Germany bans racist speech, but does not ban speech about whether racist speech ban should continue (and this particular debate is definitely alive and well in Germany). Even in the US we've banned certain words from broadcast TV for many years, but this never limited people from discussing whether the ban should continue!
- vsl 8y ago> In practice, the distinction between banning a subject and banning a conversation about a subject ban, is easy to make Apparently not for Facebook’s moderators/censors workforce. Just they other day: https://mobile.twitter.com/OzraeliAvi/status/1110400928790675456 https://mobile.twitter.com/OzraeliAvi/status/111040092879067... The day before that they banned a local satirical comics and this keeps popping up regularly.
- coldtea 8y ago>In practice, the distinction between banning a subject and banning a conversation about a subject ban, is easy to make And equally easy to abuse, something which has happened time and again: Complain about the "ban of X"? Discussion shut down as supporting X.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 8y agoGermany and the US are constitutional republics with independent judiciaries who adjudicates these things. At FB, Twitter, Snapchat etc, whoever happens to work in the subject banning division arbitrarily makes these decisions, unless overridden by top management.
- mike10010100 8y ago> There aren't that many public platforms with any reach Okay? Private organizations are under no obligation to provide you with a platform to spread your message. If you want, you can start your own social network or host your own blog.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThis is a great argument against things I didn't say.
- mike10010100 8y agoThen perhaps if you could be a little clearer about what you are saying, we could have a discussion about that.