3 ms·
I got my PhD in physics 25 years ago. One thing I quickly noticed about the article, is that it doesn't differentiate PhDs by field. When I was in school, scien
by analog31 8y ago
I got my PhD in physics 25 years ago. One thing I quickly noticed about the article, is that it doesn't differentiate PhDs by field. When I was in school, science students got PhDs in higher proportion than engineers. This might have had to do with the stronger job prospects for engineers in industry. But if you were hiring PhDs, it meant you were hiring scientists. This is definitely still the case in my workplace. PhD engineers are quite rare.
In my view it's inevitable that as one moves up the educational ladder, the amount of variation between candidates is going to increase, as will the presence of alternative paths. There is no "hiring PhDs" as if we're a fungible commodity. Much as it would gratify me for people to believe that all PhDs are magical wizards, I can't defend my entire cohort, nor should I want to. My job is to sell myself on my own merits, that's all. Don't hire anybody without looking under the hood, and without considering alternatives to what you think are your selection criteria. That's just good business sense.
At best we're going to reach the same conclusion that was discussed in recent threads about college degrees: The wisdom of economists and other experts disagrees with the collective wisdom of the market on the value of higher education. At worst, we will assign a derogatory label ("signaling") to that difference without understanding it.