6 ms·
This unions vs. education meme seems to mostly a US phenomenon as far as I can tell. As a non-USian I read a great comment here the last time it came up, pointi
by ZeroGravitas 16y ago
This unions vs. education meme seems to mostly a US phenomenon as far as I can tell. As a non-USian I read a great comment here the last time it came up, pointing out that teaching unions gained strength in the US because teachers used to get fired for such crimes as interracial dating, being seen in town after dark and basically anything else that offended the puritanical. I found that an eye-opening insight.
- mmt 16y agoI'm not sure that arbitrary firings for political reasons is relevant, either to the original article or the issue at large. What's striking to me is the unions of government employees is legal in any way, shape, or dorm. I'm pretty sure that private schools here in the US remain non-unionized.
- igrekel 16y agoI've been to a private school where the teachers were unionized. They were with a different union association than the public school teachers. This was in Canada, not in the US but I don't see why it would be different.
- mmt 16y agoI don't see why it would be different, either. I'm just unaware of it being a common phenomenon here in the US. Perhaps I'm mistaken. My main point is that there are cases where the private sector can do without unions, whereas the public sector schools cannot[1]. [1] At least in California I haven't heard of a single non-unionized public school.
- igrekel 16y agoI believe it is just a question of the number of employees and of when the organization started. Want it or not, the state is a large and visible employer.
- krakensden 16y agoNo, the arbitrary firings for political reasons /is/ relevant, it's why we have teachers unions and tenure.
- mmt 16y agoThis is merely a reiteration of the original point. I have yet to see anything persuasive as to relevance. That is, why is it any different from any other public employment? My understanding is that civil service jobs have specific legal (aka politically-sourced) protections without resorting to techniques from the private sector. ETA: Moreover, politically-motivated firings aren't necessarily arbitrary, though they're obviously not based on merit. The unionized system doesn't appear to be merit-based, either.
- krschultz 16y agoIn 2006 my AP government teacher was the subject of about a half dozen articles in the local paper and a school board meeting where about 500 angry parents came and tried to get him fired for being too liberal. It is definitely relevant.
- hugh3 16y agoFor being too liberal, or for bringing his private political beliefs into the classroom?
- krschultz 16y agoHis crime was to allow the students to have a debate on the merits of two US policies - the use of torture and the use of depleted uranium. The key point was that this wasn't his idea. He solicited topics for debate from the students in the class, those two were chosen as the topics. This got misconstrued by some parents who were offended as he pushed us to consider these questions becuase he was liberal, and thus was bringing his political beliefs into the classroom. I ended up being the lead on the team that defended torture and depleted uranium (and we won), and somehow the more difficult debate actually ended up being the one I had at the school board meeting defending him.
- duncanj 16y agoHow was the decision made on your torture/DU debates?
- krschultz 16y agoNot sure if you mean how was it decided that was going to be our topic or how it was decided who won the debate. The topic was proposed by a student in the class who had actually thought about it beforehand, no one else had any good ideas. The "winner" of the debate was determined by a panel of other teachers (part of the reason he got in trouble the teachers were "ruling" on gov't policy). Nobody seems to understand that the people (me and a few others) defending the US's policys could actually win. Everyone assumed that it was biased by his politics such that obviously the result would be anti-American. It was actually quite fun. Though I'd say that the reason my group won was largely becuase in 2006 a lot less was known about Gitmo. We could do a lot of "you can't prove that X Y or Z is happening, that is just conjecture", that we wouldn't be able to do today. As a side note, I'm firmly in the anti-toture and anti-DU camp, but I always find it more interesting in debate to side with the group you disagree with.
- hugh3 16y agoIf the US did ban teachers and other vital public employees from unionization, there would in fairness need to be corresponding changes on the employer side. Among these could be a law to prohibit firing of these employees except under conditions A, B and C.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhy? The purpose of public sector employees is to benefit the public. The government should endeavor to provide as little benefit to it's employees as possible - just enough to retain the necessary workforce. Anything else is a waste of our money. A regulation of the nature you describe would potentially harm the public - an employee might be harming the public under conditions D, but would be unable to be fired.
- hugh3 16y agoLook, the A B and C bit shouldn't be taken too seriously, just some kind of law against firing 'em for random, arbitrary and capricious reasons while still making it easy for them to be fired for doing a bad job.
- anamax 16y ago> Look, the A B and C bit shouldn't be taken too seriously, just some kind of law against firing 'em for random, arbitrary and capricious reasons while still making it easy for them to be fired for doing a bad job. Why? If you're being paid by tax dollars, taxpayers should be able to fire you for any reason that they please. If you don't like those conditions, work for someone else who offers the conditions that you'd like. Yes, your fellow tax payers may well disagree with you about how to spend tax money. That's how democracy works. If you don't want "those people" to decide how to spend "your" money, perhaps you should carefully consider when you pay directly vs via govt.
- mmt 16y agoIf you're being paid by tax dollars, taxpayers should be able to fire you for any reason that they please. I agree. The rub is that it's not usually the taxpayers making that decision, but their elected representatives. I believe there's already a commonly applied differentiation between appointed and civil service[1] positions. [1] I don't know if these are the actual terms, so corrections are welcome.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIt wasn't just teachers, it was more or less any respectable profession. Rules that programmers were subject to: "When I started at IBM there was a dress code, that was an informal oral code of white shirts. You couldn't wear anything but a white shirt, generally with a starched collar. I remember attending my first class, and a gentleman said to me as we were entering the building, are you an IBMer, and I said yes. He had a three piece suit on, vests were of the vogue, and he said could you just lift your pants leg please. I said what, and before I knew it he had lifted my pants leg and he said you're not wearing any garters. I said what?! He said your socks, they're not pulled tight to the top, you need garters. And sure enough I had to go get garters." http://www.pbs.org/nerds/part2.html http://www.pbs.org/nerds/part2.html It wasn't just the US, the UK was also very puritanical. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Turing#Conviction_for_indecency http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Turing#Conviction_for_inde... Claiming that these things were restricted to teachers, or have changed because of teachers unions is nothing but the post-hoc fallacy.
- Alex3917 16y ago"Claiming that these things were restricted to teachers, or have changed because of teachers unions is nothing but the post-hoc fallacy." The difference is that you don't have the entire town calling the CEO of IBM to get an employee fired for explaining what a condom is. While the same social norms were behind both corporate rules and also rules for school teachers, the rules for school teachers were many times stricter because of much greater pressure from the community. And if you look at the union rules for firing teachers, it's pretty clear that they were crafted in part to make it more difficult for a teacher to get fired due to a few parents putting pressure on the principal. Because if these rules didn't exist, then most principals would take the easy out and fire that teacher every time regardless of whether or not they actually did anything wrong. Because unlike at IBM, the principal doesn't lose any money for firing a good teacher; all that happens is they get rid of a headache, so the incentives are aligned to reward principals for harming students. That's why the protections currently offered by the unions are needed.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoActivists often call for corporate employees to be fired. Regardless, my point is that the highly inflammatory examples (interracial dating) cited by zerogravitas applied to all respectable professions historically, and no professions today. In the same era he is discussing (most likely < 1967 [1]), no one would tolerate interracial dating from a newspaper columnist, homosexuality from a money manager or non-whiteness from the CEO of the #3 Bank in the US. In the present era, Paul Krugman, Peter Thiel and Vikram Pandit all have jobs. Can we attribute that to teachers unions as well? As for firing the occasional good teacher, it's true that schools currently have no incentive to do a good job teaching students. This is a much bigger problem than firing unpopular teachers. Guess which organizations are the biggest proponents of keeping things that way? [1] Pre 1967, interracial marriage was illegal in some states (Virginia, at least). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loving_v._Virginia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loving_v._Virginia
- Alex3917 16y agoI'm the one who posted the comment you're referring to. I remember seeing the primary document with the complete list of rules for schoolteachers in my history of education class, but I have no idea how I'd even find it right now. If you look back through the primary documents relating to education though it's pretty crazy how much of a role religion plays. For example, the first compulsory education law in the United States was the Ye Old Deluder Satan Act, the first half of which I'll paste below: "It being one chief project of that old deluder, Satan, to keep men from the knowledge of the Scriptures, as in former times by keeping them in an unknown tongue, so in these latter times by persuading from the use of tongues, that so that at least the true sense and meaning of the original might be clouded and corrupted with love and false glosses of saint-seeming deceivers; and to the end that learning may not be buried in the grave of our forefathers, in church and commonwealth, the Lord assisting our endeavors. It is therefore ordered that every township in this jurisdiction, after the Lord hath increased them to fifty households shall forthwith appoint one within their town to teach all such children as shall resort to him to write and read, whose wages shall be paid either by the parents or masters of such children, or by the inhabitants in general, by way of supply, as the major part of those that order the prudentials of the town shall appoint; provided those that send their children be not oppressed by paying much more than they can have them taught for in other towns." Essentially the reason why it started becoming compulsory for town to build schools is that the government thought that children, if left to their own devices, would be corrupted by satan. And these same beliefs are also the basis of how we treat not only our children, but also our school teachers right up to this day. Hardly a week goes by in the US where there isn't a story about a teacher being fired for having a picture of themselves drinking on Facebook, breaking up an assault on a gay student, assigning a book that mentions sex, etc. Of course this mostly happens in small towns in the south; the more 'enlightened' areas of the country have already mostly switched to having their teachers teach f om entirely pre-made curricula geared toward passing standardized tests, a system which was implemented partly to prevent these 'problems' from occurring. Also, if I remember correctly even pg once commented that the reason he wasn't allowed to give his high school graduation speech is that the principal wouldn't have been able to get him fired if the parents complained.
- roc 16y ago> "This unions vs. education meme seems to mostly a US phenomenon as far as I can tell." Further, we've had teachers' unions for generations. (AFT was founded in 1916) But every now and again, there's a flurry of stories about how education is 'broken', and teachers' unions are the problem. This is all followed and subsumed by the stories about how we all know schools are broken and teachers unions are the problem (begging two questions in the classical sense), but charter schools (specifically) are the solution. (Despite studies having shown since the last round of this meme, that while some charter schools are superior most are inferior, and overall their average performance is notably lower than the public schools they're supposed to 'fix'.) It's enough to make you wonder where it all comes from.