3 ms·
This article isn't very good. Half of it is about 51% attacks, which is the one attack blockchains were always transparent about, and the other half talks about
by StavrosK 8y ago
This article isn't very good. Half of it is about 51% attacks, which is the one attack blockchains were always transparent about, and the other half talks about how some smart contracts are buggy. Cool.
- travellingprog 8y agoThe issue isn't just that some smart contracts are buggy. After all, all software should be expected to have bugs at some point. The bigger issues are that a)the source code can be very visible, making it easier to figure out how to exploit than traditional code running in an isolated server, and b)recovering from an attack can be incredibly difficult (such as needing to create a fork of the blockchain pre-attack).
- arisAlexis 8y agoI don't thikk anyone read the article most upvotes come from the blockchain hate title
- arisAlexis 8y agolike the downvotes of this comment. there is significant bias in the space
- exelius 8y agoThe blockchain developers were always transparent about 51% attacks, but it turned out to be far more plausible in a scaled network than was expected. The viability of 51% attacks are a result of the business deals surrounding the ecosystem, not any technical deficiency in the code. Personally, I think the entire concept of cryptocurrency is flawed because it punts on the governance problem. Ditto for smart contracts. People / companies like to have the ability to dispute the outcome of a transaction, and you really can’t do that without vesting authority in a governing body to overrule the technology. But then, if you have a central authority that has the power to modify transactions, do you really need blockchain?
- Fellshard 8y agoAlways remember: it's not actually about removing trust, it's about shifting trust. And when you look at it in that light, most of these technologies become a lot hairier then they're worth.
- seldon 8y agoCould you elaborate on this? It's an interesting comment
- eridius 8y agoOne of the main selling points of cryptocurrencies is decentralization, of not needing to trust a central party in order to use the currency. But the cryptocurrency doesn't actually eliminate that trust, it simply moves it. It moves it into trusting the protocol design, trusting the implementation of the clients, trusting your local hardware and OS to not be compromised, and in the case of smart contracts, trusting the smart contract to not be buggy. What's worse is in the centralized case, as long as the government continues to function you have lots of options for what to do if a transaction goes badly. In the cryptocurrency case, for the most part you're SOL, because cryptocurrencies by design don't allow anyone to e.g. void a transaction.
- 8y ago