2 ms·
The problem is, by being intolerant (even of the intolerant), you're intolerant. So if the "paradox of tolerance" is accurate, then we must not tolerate you.
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
The problem is, by being intolerant (even of the intolerant), you're intolerant. So if the "paradox of tolerance" is accurate, then we must not tolerate you.
"But", you say, "they were intolerant first, so they are the ones who should not be tolerated!" From your perspective, sure. Maybe not from theirs, though. That gets you to a cycle of each side being sure that the other is intolerant, and therefore that their own intolerance is justified. Maybe this "paradox of tolerance" isn't the right way forward, even in the face of intolerance by others. You should be better than them, not imitate them.
Worse, if each side can think that the other side started it, well, what if the other side is right? What if you actually are the problem? Using the "paradox of tolerance" as your justification is a handy way to justify your own intolerance, and never have to examine yourself.
- anigbrowl 8y agoNeo-nazis and their ilk tend to be pretty explicit about wanting to kill specific groups of people as part of their ideology, something which your hypothesis seems to overlook.
- NoodleIncident 8y agoWow! I guess both sides are the same in every situation in which two groups disagree, and there are no right answers to anything. I'm shocked it was so easy to prove this, once and for all! It sure would be inconvenient if anyone pulled back the curtain on this intentionally-vague comment to show that you're equating "Nazis" with "People who disagree with Nazis"!
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThose who are actually observant rather than just snarky might notice that I said no such thing. What I actually said is, first, when you don't tolerate intolerance, you become (at least in technique) similar to the people you are fighting. And second, don't be so sure that you aren't the bad guys. And the more absolutely sure you are that you're the good guys, the more I want you to back off and take a really hard look at whether that is actually true, because the bad guys can use exactly your logic (or at least gameskrishnan's) to convince themselves that they're the good guys.
- qualipetv 8y agoWhat utter garbage. So many centuries of war and suffering, millions and millions of pages written on the events of the 20th century and still there’s people taking themselves out of the equation and saying that actually, the guys loving freedom and who would rather not live under fascist rule are really the bad guys. Please educate yourself and read about all our collective achievements and try to understand where the vehemence of people not wanting to tolerate nazis comes from.
- tomhoward 8y ago> What utter garbage This opening, along with your straw man in the second sentence, shows that you're not debating this topic in good faith. It would be nice to think that every horrific event in history was simply a case of bad people knowingly doing bad things. Sure, sometimes it is, when we're talking about a lone actor or despotic leader who just wants to bring about destruction and misery for their own pathological reasons. But at least as often, everyone thinks they're the good ones fighting for a just cause. As has often been said here before, one person's terrorist is another's freedom fighter. One person's liberating saviour is another's tyrannical occupying force. It might be easy for us to look at 1930s-40s Europe and judge which side was right and which was wrong, but to an ordinary German or Italian citizen or soldier who didn't have a full understanding of what was going on, and just knew that their country had been economically depressed for too long, it wasn't so clear. And in plenty of other major conflicts since then, the rightness or wrongness of each side is very hard to discern. This is not suggesting that racism or bigotry is ever to be endorsed or validated. But bigotry is usually an expression of a deeper distress that has nothing to do with the target of the bigotry. It's often just scapegoating for a largely unrelated problem. By paying attention to what the real source of that distress is (e.g., post-WW1 misery), it's possible to respond to the real problem and prevent the bigotry and consequent horrors from developing at all.
- qualipetv 8y agoNo, it's objectively garbage to take yourself out of the equation and accept fascism like it's not going to hurt anyone. I'm not going in retrospective here and say my judgement would have been perfect 80 years ago. I say we need to learn from past developments and mistakes made in the course of history. Stop abstracting away the problem at hand which is White Nationalism and other fascist thought becoming more and more acceptable. > By paying attention to what the real source of that distress is (e.g., post-WW1 misery) You think you have it all figured out and you 'get it' now. That's naive in my opinion. And I'm not talking about good and bad, some kind of universalist dualism that informs my every action; I'm talking about being concerned about my friends that may or may not fit certain views on human existence that fascist thought provides. At least try to get where I'm coming from instead of throwing out useless internet jargon ('strawman') without even understanding why I'm reacting so harshly.