4 ms·
Anyone think it strange that a phone company wouldn't see the emergence of the smartphone? Guffawed when I saw those phone booth picture phones.
by rmason 8y ago
Anyone think it strange that a phone company wouldn't see the emergence of the smartphone?
Guffawed when I saw those phone booth picture phones.
- msla 8y ago> Anyone think it strange that a phone company wouldn't see the emergence of the smartphone? > Guffawed when I saw those phone booth picture phones. It's how these things usually work: The Future Is The Same, But Different The Same: Things basically click along they way they do now. Want to make a call away from home or office? Use a payphone. Most natural thing in the world. But Different: Well, payphones aren't going to stay the same, are they? Videophones have been a Coming Thing for decades now, so obviously we'll have Video Payphones. All of those Coming Things. Where have they all gone? The interesting thing to me is this: Car phones had existed for decades by that point. They'd slimmed down to bag phones for the masses, and bricks for Gordon Gekko and his proteges. But AT&T didn't prognosticate their continued slimming driving payphones into irrelevance. You don't even need the smartphone concept, which was a truly interesting convergence of cell phone and computer, to get the idea that "Cell phones getting smaller" leads to "I can carry a phone with me" leads to "I don't need a payphone" leads to payphones no longer existing. Oh, and Bag Phone, because nobody else seems to remember them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_Bag_Phone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_Bag_Phone
- ssewell 8y agoGood insight! Really rings true when the guy "faxes" from the beach. They had the foresight for ubiquitous remote access, but not for a modern messaging platform. :)
- philwelch 8y agoThe collective imagination of all of humanity, when presented with new technology 20 years in the future, is always going to discover implications that any futurist or group of futurists would never think of.
- CamperBob2 8y agoTo be fair it was AT&T who took a chance on the iPhone, after the other major carriers had told Jobs to go pound sand and industry figures like Ballmer had publicly laughed at him. I could see him using these commercials in his pitch to AT&T. "You said we would. It's time."
- xattt 8y agoCingular did, who was then bought up by AT&T.
- kxrm 8y agoCingular had nothing to do with AT&T. SBC and Bell South (2 baby bells) were who had Cingular, SBC acquired AT&T and took the name in 2005.
- walrus01 8y agoCingular was the cellular carrier that signed the contract to be the exclusive carrier for the iPhone, in something like January 2007. Between the time they signed it and the release of the iPhone at retail, they were acquired by att cellular.
- kxrm 8y agoAT&T by that time was a completely different company. Southwestern Bell is now who owns the trademark and name AT&T. The AT&T company that made this commercial was largely irrelevant by 2005.
- mdasen 8y agoThe tablet that they show sending a fax from the beach is essentially a smartphone. The thing is that smartphones weren't popular until Apple even though they had existed. Palm, Nokia/Symbian, Danger, and Microsoft had been pushing smartphones before the iPhone came out. BlackBerry was pushing non-touch smartphones as well. The issue is that none of them really had a compelling user experience before Apple came along. You can say that the iPhone was obvious, but no one else saw to use capacitive touchscreens at the time. Even after the iPhone came out, everyone thought that the lack of a physical keyboard was Apple's hubris and would be their downfall. Windows Mobile, Symbian, and PalmOS didn't integrate a first-class web browsing experience. Heck, I remember Windows Mobile emphasizing scroll bars rather than the natural movement that Apple introduced with the iPhone, never mind pinch to zoom. Apple came along and showed everyone what the point of having a smartphone in your pocket was. You'd have the best music experience. You'd have the full internet for any question you'd ever have. You'd have maps. You'd have a great photos experience. Part of that is that they recognized that the capacitive technology they'd been using in iPods and trackpads for years could be used as part of a fuller operating system. Part of it is that they really spent a lot of time figuring out how people could use a touchscreen well. Others had just tried to take desktop UI concepts and put them on a touch device. AT&T saw the emergence of the smartphone. Heck, Microsoft, Palm, Nokia/Symbian, BlackBerry, Danger, and even Google tried to build it before Apple (Google was targeting Symbian and had to "go back to the drawing board" when the iPhone was introduced). They all missed the key affordances that would drive consumer adoption. Google's pre-iPhone prototypes were basically BlackBerry/Symbian competitors. Microsoft wanted scroll bars, a start menu, and windows. Even after the iPhone, many tried pushing devices with keyboards: Moto Droid, HTC's first Android device, the Palm Pre, etc. It's not about saying "we'll have X in the future!" People saw smartphones/tablets. Heck, Star Trek had tablets in late 80s, but they didn't need them to be usable, just props. People just never figured out how to make them compelling for users before Apple did.
- msla 8y ago> The tablet that they show sending a fax from the beach is essentially a smartphone. Except for the fact it's sending a fax. Smartphones don't send faxes, but they could. They don't because they exist in a world where faxing someone something is a niche application, and approximately nobody would buy a smartphone based on how well it faxes. The technological culture is different. The world has changed in more ways than just "We can stick a good computer in your pocket and power it all day long" and AT&T didn't predict that. I realize I'm partially repeating some elements of your comment, but I do have my own point to make here: In looking at history, avoid Presentism. Try to see the past on its own terms, not through the lens of the modern day. That is a learned skill, and not having it is shown by crediting people in the past with predicting things they never thought of.
- hrktb 8y agoI might not be getting it, didn’t the videos also feature a PDA like device which is basically how they saw the future of portability, which is not far from our smartphones I think.
- dredmorbius 8y ago2001, in 1968: https://youtube.com/watch?v=5T1UGfm_OMM https://youtube.com/watch?v=5T1UGfm_OMM Even accurately predicts portrait-mode video. See also the "minisec" from Arthur C. Clarke's Imperial Earth (1976): Duncan Makenzie had a new minisec, and he was not quite sure how parts of it worked. The 'Sec was the standard size of all such units, determined by what can fit comfortably in the human hand. At a quick glance, it did not differ greatly from one of the small electronic calculators that had started coming into general use at the end of the twentieth century. It was, however, infinitely more versatile, and Duncan could not imagine what life would be like without it. Because of the finite size of clumsy human fingers, it had no more controls than that of its ancestor of three hundred years earlier. There were fifty neat little studs; each, however, had an unlimited number of functions, according to the mode of operation - for the character visible on each stud changed according to the mode. http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/content.asp?Bnum=1267 http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/content.asp?Bnum=1267 Others: https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/93979/did-science-fiction-anticipate-a-device-like-a-smartphone https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/93979/did-science-...
- jonas21 8y agoFor these ads to succeed, they not only had to present a vision of the future, they also had to do so in a way that someone watching the ad could understand in just a few seconds. That doesn't leave much time for explanation. So they chose to present things in a way that the average person in 1993 could relate to. Everyone would have been familiar with calling home from a pay phone when traveling -- so it would make sense to present a future where video calling is done from a pay phone. That doesn't necessarily mean AT&T thought this is exactly how the future would play out.