Okay, I don't disagree with your premise. And I was a small time pirate before Spotify and the like. But couldn't you legally copy music between devices withou

Okay, I don't disagree with your premise. And I was a small time pirate before Spotify and the like. But couldn't you legally copy music between devices without being a pirate? Also, surely nobody tried to have music for an MP3 player AND a Walkman. Those have got to be mutually exclusive, don't they? Even smartphones and MP3 players didn't exist together much. I personally started paying for Spotify to help myself feel more ethical about my music consumption. And it is very convenient. Except I haven't ponyed up for the family price yet, so only one person in my family can use it at a time.