4 ms·

White is not an ethnic nationality. A person from Ireland has no ethnic or national ties to a person from Italy. The fact that the citizens of those two countri

White is not an ethnic nationality. A person from Ireland has no ethnic or national ties to a person from Italy. The fact that the citizens of those two countries were not considered "white" 100 years ago demonstrates the invalidity of "white" as an ethnic or national group.

patagonian 8y ago
> White is not an ethnic nationality This is not true for all intents and purposes, and it's bizarre to mention nationality in a thread about white nationalism. "Ethnicity" refers to both fine-grained and broader ethnic identification. Being black is absolutely an ethnicity, while being Yoruba is too. By looking at an White American's DNA profile, one can predict their ethnic identificationwith 98% accuracy.Historically thiss was also the case, it's just that Christianity was the standardmarker for being European/white. Even if that weren't true, being white is still an ethnic group as people perceive it today > A person from Ireland has no ethnic or national ties to a person from Italy They do, it's called being ethnically European. The Irish and Italians share a genetic similarity, historical, religious, cultural, and linguistic affinity. Consider how much closer to Algeria Italy is, yet Algerians and Italians share none of these similarities and gues what... Algerians aren't white. > The fact that the citizens of those two countries were not considered "white" 100 years ago demonstrates the invalidity of "white" as an ethnic or national group. This is completely and demostrably untrue. The U.S. Naturalisation Act of 1790 and the following acts limited U.S. immigration to "whites of good character". In this period, more immigrants came from Ireland and Italy combined than nearly anywhere else.Ben Franklin even specifically referred to Irish as white. Your comment demonstrates the invalidity of your knowledge of this topic to be honest
toomim 8y ago
The way I see race actually agrees with you, but the issue is that "white nationalists" DO see themselves as a race and ethnicity: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism It's in the first sentence of their description: > White nationalism is a type of nationalism or pan-nationalism which espouses the belief that white people are a race and seeks to develop and maintain a white national identity.

patagonian 8y ago

> White is not an ethnic nationality This is not true for all intents and purposes, and it's bizarre to mention nationality in a thread about white nationalism. "Ethnicity" refers to both fine-grained and broader ethnic identification. Being black is absolutely an ethnicity, while being Yoruba is too. By looking at an White American's DNA profile, one can predict their ethnic identificationwith 98% accuracy.Historically thiss was also the case, it's just that Christianity was the standardmarker for being European/white. Even if that weren't true, being white is still an ethnic group as people perceive it today > A person from Ireland has no ethnic or national ties to a person from Italy They do, it's called being ethnically European. The Irish and Italians share a genetic similarity, historical, religious, cultural, and linguistic affinity. Consider how much closer to Algeria Italy is, yet Algerians and Italians share none of these similarities and gues what... Algerians aren't white. > The fact that the citizens of those two countries were not considered "white" 100 years ago demonstrates the invalidity of "white" as an ethnic or national group. This is completely and demostrably untrue. The U.S. Naturalisation Act of 1790 and the following acts limited U.S. immigration to "whites of good character". In this period, more immigrants came from Ireland and Italy combined than nearly anywhere else.Ben Franklin even specifically referred to Irish as white. Your comment demonstrates the invalidity of your knowledge of this topic to be honest

toomim 8y ago

The way I see race actually agrees with you, but the issue is that "white nationalists" DO see themselves as a race and ethnicity: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism It's in the first sentence of their description: > White nationalism is a type of nationalism or pan-nationalism which espouses the belief that white people are a race and seeks to develop and maintain a white national identity.