6 ms·
More security holes are appearing in cryptocurrency and smart contract platforms
- rmason 8y agoIf you're not a subscriber: https://outline.com/v3AKbj https://outline.com/v3AKbj
- intelliderp 8y ago"Blockchain" isn't a good descriptor for the set of properties that the Bitcoin protocol relies on for tamper resistance, so it's no surprise that other "blockchain"-having systems don't share that resistance. "Proof of work" is a much more accurate descriptor, but it's been tainted in the media to mean "evil climate-destroying obsolete thing." Most software hype cycles don't affect anyone but developers, but if this blockchain thing continues on, there's going to be a lot of money stolen.
- howiroll 8y agoThat’s not a blockchain.
- StavrosK 8y agoThis article isn't very good. Half of it is about 51% attacks, which is the one attack blockchains were always transparent about, and the other half talks about how some smart contracts are buggy. Cool.
- travellingprog 8y agoThe issue isn't just that some smart contracts are buggy. After all, all software should be expected to have bugs at some point. The bigger issues are that a)the source code can be very visible, making it easier to figure out how to exploit than traditional code running in an isolated server, and b)recovering from an attack can be incredibly difficult (such as needing to create a fork of the blockchain pre-attack).
- arisAlexis 8y agoI don't thikk anyone read the article most upvotes come from the blockchain hate title
- arisAlexis 8y agolike the downvotes of this comment. there is significant bias in the space
- exelius 8y agoThe blockchain developers were always transparent about 51% attacks, but it turned out to be far more plausible in a scaled network than was expected. The viability of 51% attacks are a result of the business deals surrounding the ecosystem, not any technical deficiency in the code. Personally, I think the entire concept of cryptocurrency is flawed because it punts on the governance problem. Ditto for smart contracts. People / companies like to have the ability to dispute the outcome of a transaction, and you really can’t do that without vesting authority in a governing body to overrule the technology. But then, if you have a central authority that has the power to modify transactions, do you really need blockchain?
- Fellshard 8y agoAlways remember: it's not actually about removing trust, it's about shifting trust. And when you look at it in that light, most of these technologies become a lot hairier then they're worth.
- seldon 8y agoCould you elaborate on this? It's an interesting comment
- eridius 8y agoOne of the main selling points of cryptocurrencies is decentralization, of not needing to trust a central party in order to use the currency. But the cryptocurrency doesn't actually eliminate that trust, it simply moves it. It moves it into trusting the protocol design, trusting the implementation of the clients, trusting your local hardware and OS to not be compromised, and in the case of smart contracts, trusting the smart contract to not be buggy. What's worse is in the centralized case, as long as the government continues to function you have lots of options for what to do if a transaction goes badly. In the cryptocurrency case, for the most part you're SOL, because cryptocurrencies by design don't allow anyone to e.g. void a transaction.
- 8y ago
- paulgb 8y agoHas anyone analyzed the effect that the next Bitcoin halving will have on the cost of a 51% attack? It seems to me that on one hand, there will be less incentive to mine and so the global hash rate will drop. At the same time a bunch of miners would become unprofitable and therefore there would be an oversupply of mining capacity (assuming there is an efficient way to rent it.) It seems like a perfect-storm event to me, but in my very casual interest I have not seen any attempts to analyze the effect of this on the 51% attack risk.
- chrisco255 8y agoUsually halvenings cause a subsequent boost to the price per Bitcoin.
- im3w1l 8y agoThat's historical accident and wont(can't) continue to hold.
- chrisco255 8y agoNo that's simply supply / demand economics. Miners dump their mined Bitcoin on the market immediately after mining. When a halvening occurs, that means less BTC are dumped on the market daily. Assuming demand remains the same, prices will increase.
- aeternus 8y agoTrue, however many people are likely expecting this to happen and there are now many more methods to perform arbitrage on Bitcoin That could soften this, it is more likely to be priced-in well before the actual event.
- josephagoss 8y agoAnyone interested in a security first cryptocurrency you should check out Tezos. Tezos uses proof of stake with a bond requirement that should solve the nothing at stake problem. The two big issues with proof of work is that it uses massive amounts of energy and unless you're the top coin or among the top 5 the chances someone will easily 51% attack your network is high. Also Tezos uses a formal programming language for its smart contracts that should help reduce certain types of bugs. It's an interesting project and as a disclaimer I own some. The project had many growing pains but is on its feet now and I think that their first on chain governance vote went through recently, meaning the codebase can be updated in a decentralized manner.
- obulpathi 8y agoNot sure why your comment is being down voted. Decentralized Governance and formal verification of smart contracts of Tezos are really good!
- temp0876456 8y agoTo clarify a few things: 1. The first vote passed successfully into stage 2 meaning a protocol upgrade has been selected and is being voted on for inclusion. 2. Smart contracts are written in Michelson, a stack based language that can be formally verified. Other user friendly languages have been built on top of it. 3. The software of Tezos is written in OCaml which can also be formally verified. 4. There have been several security audits and, as far as I know, no issues were found. 5. Tezos has never been hacked. 6. It uses a unique flavor of PoS called Liquid PoS. It is designed to be as decentralized as possible meaning the barriers for becoming a baker (equiv. to a Bitcoin miner) are very low. 7. #6 is also designed to make voting as decentralized as possible.
- apo 8y agoThe subtitle is misleading: > Once hailed as unhackable, blockchains are now getting hacked This might be fine if the article didn't talk at such length about majority hash rate attacks. It implies that this kind of attack is something new, which it most certainly is not. You can think of a soft fork (one path to upgrading the network) as a coordinated majority hash rate attack. A cartel decides that they will censor blocks that don't conform to a restricted version of the protocol. Whether you call it an attack depends maybe on intent, but the mechanism is identical. The Bitcoin white paper explains very clearly the main security assumption: an attacker does not control a majority of the hash power. It's been part of the security model from the beginning. Most of the other attacks have been launched against Ethereum. Its scripting system is quite a bit more complex than Bitcion's, so its attack surface is larger.
- mettamage 8y agoHello HN! :D I’m going to ask a controversial question. If it is too controversial, just downvote and I will keep it in mind. Feel free to reply with a throwaway with your IP spoofed and all that jazz. Who of you have decided to hack cryptocurrencies in order to make some money? How was the journey like? How do you feel about it morally? As for me, I obviously haven’t done it, otherwise I would ask this on a throwaway. I thought about doing it. But I don’t want to steal and a minor point is that I would find it boring. Why am I asking this: a candid response would make for an interesting read. There was once an AMA on Reddit about a malware writer. It was fascinating!