5 ms·
It's OK to say you believe that you are pro free-speech only in cases of government/military/police censorship. It's not OK to redefine free speech to mean "gov
by gowld 8y ago
It's OK to say you believe that you are pro free-speech only in cases of government/military/police censorship. It's not OK to redefine free speech to mean "government censorship", especially not to call your position "very nearly absolutist".
You believe that private companies have the moral right to censor and filter user-generated content. That's your opinion/morality. But it's not "free speech absolutism" in the common English language.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago> It's not OK to redefine free speech to mean "government censorship" I beg to disagree, and in fact I believe you are the one that is redefining free speech. "Free speech" as I have known it has always referred just to government restrictions, because the government is the only entity that has the very unique punative powers that they do. Indeed, a strong corrolary to free speech, freedom of the press, by definition means that a (private) journalism organization is free to publish (or not publish) whatever they want. I do agree that the relatively new, immense power of large technology companies with respect to how we communicate may require a sense of updating what we mean by "free speech", but this would be an update - it is not inherent to the original meaning of free speech.
- throwawaysea 8y agoFree speech means freedom from censorship. And from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship > Censorship is the suppression of speech, public communication, or other information, on the basis that such material is considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or "inconvenient". Censorship can be conducted by a government, private institutions, and corporations. From Merriam-Webster (https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/censorship https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/censorship), where there is no mention of 'censorship' being a government-specific concept: > the institution, system, or practice of censoring From Oxford (https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/censorship https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/censorship), where again there is no mention of 'censorship' being a government-specific concept: > The suppression or prohibition of any parts of books, films, news, etc. that are considered obscene, politically unacceptable, or a threat to security.
- stronglikedan 8y ago> Free speech means freedom from censorship. As I understand it, it means freedom only from prosecution, but not persecution or censorship. I agree with GP in that this is their platform and their rules.
- JakeTheAndroid 8y agoIf you take all of this out of context, sure I see where you are coming from. But in context this is simply being pedantic. Facebook is a US based company. When talking about Freedom of Speech in America, it's almost exclusively used to refer to the Constitutional protections around Freedom of Speech, as that is the only codified Free Speech parameters for the country at large. So in context, OP would be saying that they are near absolutist on Freedom of Speech as it relates to the Constitution. I don't know many people that would interpret Freedom of Speech as a more generalized concept unless it was defined before hand.
- zamalek 8y agoYou are referring to the most common definition. The are, in fact, many. The parent comment is referring to absolutist FoS. This form of FoS implies that you do not have the right to walk away from a discussion: the speaker has "the right to be heard" and you do not have the "right to ignore." If someone were to post involuntary pornography of you online, that would be their FoS and you wouldn't be able to issue a take-down. This type of FoS is ludicrous because it sacrifices so many other freedoms to achieve purity in a single freedom. The common definition of FoS deals mainly with government censorship and fighting words. The government must step in to protect the speech of someone if they are not violating the rights of others; conversely the government must stop speech that might result in the rights of others being violated (e.g. promoting violence towards a group). This approximates the UDHR definition, which is basically the "dictionary definition" of FoS (even this definition has been amended).
- guelo 8y agoNo, it is your redefinition that is the new one. And the right-wing is not standing on consistent principles when they try to self-servingly redefine freedom as the individual's freedom to appropriate a company's private property only for the case of popular social networks and nothing else.
- stcredzero 8y agoAnd the right-wing is not standing on consistent principles when they try to self-servingly redefine freedom as the individual's freedom to appropriate a company's private property only for the case of popular social networks and nothing else. False. As the Marsh case demonstrates, Free Speech takes priority over property rights. No inconsistency there.
- Analemma_ 8y agoGreat! Then you have no legal grounds to oppose me when I hold a political rally on your front lawn tomorrow. See you then!
- stcredzero 8y agoGreat! Then you have no legal grounds to oppose me when I hold a political rally on your front lawn tomorrow. See you then! False. Targeted harassment of private individuals is against the law, and does not fall under Free Speech. Also, I do not have a lawn. You will know them by their deeds. Can't convince? Instead, intimidate. Can't convince? Instead coerce. Thanks for showing your true authoritarian colors.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> As the Marsh case demonstrates, Free Speech takes priority over property rights. As the "subsequent history" section of the Marsh v. Alabama Wikipedia entry indicates, not always. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lloyd_Corp._v._Tanner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lloyd_Corp._v._Tanner
- 8y ago
- tssva 8y agoThe definition of free speech has historically also included the right not to be compelled to produce speech against your will. It could be argued that requiring companies to reproduce speech against their will is more a violation of "free speech absolutism" than defending their right not to do so.