3 ms·
Am familiar with George, but hadn't put this together before: > Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those imp
by mixmastamyk 8y ago
Am familiar with George, but hadn't put this together before:
> Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those improvements will be captured mainly by other parties.
Always wondered why some folks want the city to be as shitty as possible. First compelling reason I've read.
- rootusrootus 8y agoBut does it really work that way? I.e. the effect may be real enough, but among the non-landowners, who actually considers that the net effect of improving the city would result in them personally paying more to live there?
- mixmastamyk 8y agoSee my cousin comment. Many vocal folks online in the neighborhood, though don't know their numbers are significant or not. (Measure S in Los Angeles was soundly defeated.) In another neighborhood (East LA) new businesses were vandalized allegedly by anti-gentrification groups.
- gowld 8y agoThey don't want the city to be as shitty as possible. They want to be able to get what they can afford. Here's an analogy: Imagine if Apple drove all PC competitors out of the market, fair and square, by making a lovely product that is expensive, to the point and PC makers couldn't sustainably sell low-cost lower-quality PCs. Imagine you can't afford an Apple Mac, but you cold have afford a low-cost lower-quality PC. You'd suffer becuase the world is passing you by and leaving you out. Would you be wrong for opposing Apple's business in any way you can? If you are exlucded from the social contract, you have no obligation to uphold it.
- mixmastamyk 8y ago> They don't want... You haven't read the facebook comments in our neighborhood group, where even the upgrade of a crumbling parking lot or flop house covered in graffiti to a modest apartment building meets howls of protest and "disgust."