3 ms·
>I think my arms dealer provides a much clearer example of facts removed from tech where people in HN are understandably defensive. guns are much simpler situa
by trhway 8y ago
>I think my arms dealer provides a much clearer example of facts removed from tech where people in HN are understandably defensive.
guns are much simpler situation, and this is why it doesn't make the situation clearer. Imagine if that specific gun dealer could look into the brain of a buyer. Would you hold him accountable for not checking the Parkland shooter's brain?
>the law does create liability if the seller knew or should have known the buyer intended to use the good/service in the commission of a crime.
Is SaaS company "should have known" what is in the data it is SaaS-ing? We know that the answer is "yes" for banks according to the explicitly written money laundering, etc. laws. There arent such explicit laws for SaaS, for Facebook, etc. Is Facebook liable if somebody uses it organize a crime like say a bank robbery or an unpermitted protest?
- will_brown 8y ago>Imagine if that specific gun dealer could look into the brain of a buyer. Would you hold him accountable for not checking the Parkland shooter's brain? It’s an interesting thought experiment, but that’s not the legal burden of sellers to crawl into the mind of the purchaser. Further, it’s not about selling an item that is used in a crime, it’s selling an item you know or should know will be used in a crime. I don’t know enough about the parkland shooter purchases but it’s at least possible: 1. The shooter didn’t have intent to commit a crime when he purchased the gun/ammo and only developed the intent later after the purchase (no liability for the seller under this theory), or 2. The seller didn’t know the shooters intent and there are no facts suggesting the seller should have known. The Law and application of the same has more common sense than saying a seller should have known...if only they read the mind of the buyer.