4 ms·
I am not a ‘white person’ (whatever that means) ...but I don’t want to see ‘white nationalist content’ banned. When people communicate on a public platform uns
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
I am not a ‘white person’ (whatever that means) ...but I don’t want to see ‘white nationalist content’ banned.
When people communicate on a public platform unself consciously, they reveal themselves openly and freely. There is no greater protection to vulnerable populations than transparency. Freedom of speech is a gift and a valuable tool.This move is dumb beyond words.
- anth_anm 8y ago> There is no greater protection to vulnerable populations than transparency This is somewhat true, but your argument has a pretty big flaw. > When people communicate on a public platform unself consciously, they reveal themselves openly and freely This simply isn't true. You aren't revealing that you read this content. THe authors aren't always revealing themselves. Those who don't really do themselves any harm because they tend to be well established as white supremacists already. Richard Spencer doesn't care if someone calls him racist and evil. This is why people take photos and plaster them online when white supremacists march. People get recognized, that's the point where they can be called out. > Freedom of speech is a gift and a valuable tool. These people are radicalizing young men into committing violent acts. They should be banned the same way terrorist content has been removed from other platforms.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI think terrorist content is different from nationalism/racism. The latter is still a deeply held belief. Regardless of how we feel about it, everyone has the right to feel love or hate or superiority. This is really a failure of state to install controls and protections from out of control elements. This is a breakdown of state measures to deter/punish unlawful acts and failure to protect WHEN actions occur rather than breakdown of society. One cannot make an entire society conform. To me, that’s terrorism too.
- CamperBob2 8y agoThis is a breakdown of state measures to deter/punish unlawful acts and failure to protect WHEN actions occur rather than breakdown of society. You could say that Facebook has effectively privatized prior restraint, given the "town square" arguments made elsewhere in the thread. Great when we happen to agree with the views being restrained, I suppose.
- anth_anm 8y ago> The latter is still a deeply held belief and I need to kill the <undesirable group> isn't sincerely held? I think you have to believe pretty sincerely to be radicalized to the point of committing murder. > Regardless of how we feel about it, everyone has the right to feel love or hate or superiority. Why? I was perfectly happy living in a society where that was not the case. Where freedom of expression is guaranteed, rather than absolute freedom of speech. It's not flawless, but it's better than nazis murdering people all the damn time.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThis action doesn’t have an impact. If one thinks racism will erode because Facebook redirects one to a page imploring one to not hate, then I don’t think one has been on the receiving end of racism at all. If anything..driving free speech..however hateful..to dark recesses with only a willing or curious audience ...and without the judge mental and opposite view in the public..will only make the situation worse. Nasties multiply faster when they are not witnessed. On a simple level, think of an ocd monologue about whether your malaise is flu...vs checking with a doctor and he declares you ill(or well). Being witnessed is a huge deal. It affects people’s opinion of themselves. It is well known that we behave better when we know we are being watched.
- azernik 8y ago> The latter is still a deeply held belief. And Salafi Jihadism isn't? I have some Saudis and Pakistanis I should introduce you to...
- zcid 8y ago> This is why people take photos and plaster them online when white supremacists march. People get recognized, that's the point where they can be called out. I've found it interesting that the supposed "bad guys" are willing to openly espouse their views while the opposing side frequently utilizes masks to hide their identity.
- anth_anm 8y ago> I've found it interesting that the supposed "bad guys" Friend, if you aren't willing to condemn the white supremacists as the bad guys I seriously question your decision making. There is zero value in maintaining this veneer of both sides being in any way the same.
- zcid 8y agoI've talked to some people that didn't seem so much white supremacists as pro-white. They were mostly concerned about the willingness for society to ignore attacks on white people while vilifying the smallest transgressions against other groups. I've also seen the violence from the masked, hard-left types while never any initiated from the other side. At least in some parts of the US. I can't speak for what occurs in Europe.
- DanBC 8y ago> I've also seen the violence from the masked, hard-left types while never any initiated from the other side. In Europe and the US the main sources of terrorism are i) the far right, ii) Islamic extremists, and then a long way behind iii) animal rights and environmental extremists. If you haven't seen far-right violence it's because you're not looking. It's pervasive.
- zcid 8y agoI'm sure it (far-right violence) exists. But most of the videos I have seen online show antifa initiating violence. As far as I can tell, antifa seem to be the soldiers for the extreme left. Are we just more willing to accept their behavior because they are fighting for the "correct" side?
- WhompingWindows 8y agoHow do you transparently protect those in Christchurch NZ or at one of the sites of nationalist, extremist violence? Transparency does nothing to deter the mentally ill and psychotic individuals who perpetrate mass murder.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoBeing aware of people and surroundings in their true form is better than gagging some of the people around us, yes? We have been hating on others not like ourselves since the caveman days. I honestly can’t think of any time in history when we haven’t been doing horrible things to each other. It’s like cancer. We are able to diagnose it and hear more about it now. It’s like saying ...we are going to install a ban on sharing that you have cancer. “If we don’t know about it, we don’t have to acknowledge that there is a terminal illness amongst some of us. And all will be fine and dandy.”
- anigbrowl 8y agoYes and no. It's definitely better if you're in the business of tracking down violent extremists and interrupting their recruitment or action plans. On the other hand, not everyone is cut out for that and it's unreasonable to expect everyone to do that all the time for themselves. Rather than gagging certain people, anti-racism and CVE focuses on raising the cost of certain kinds of speech acts, specifically ones that are less about intellectual inquiry than about intimidation and coercion, which behavior may endorse or actually escalate into violent physical acts. Despite the aphorism 'sticks and stones may break by bones but words can never hurt me', hate speech imposes a significant burden on the unwilling recipient from general anxiety up to full-on fight or flight reactions, and the infliction of this burden is deliberate and strategic. It seems entirely reasonable to me that the people who want to engage in such speech should experience for themselves how their speech acts feel for the recipients.
- 8y ago