3 ms·
He complains that UBI would funnel more money to the people producing goods. At the end he advocates "universal basic assets," distributing ownership of product
by DennisP 8y ago
He complains that UBI would funnel more money to the people producing goods. At the end he advocates "universal basic assets," distributing ownership of productive assets instead of just income. If anything it's more left-wing than UBI.
- frenchy 8y ago> distributing ownership of productive assets instead of just income Yeah, that's pretty much standard communism ("collective ownership of the means of production"). The million dollar question, is "how do we go about doing this without setting up a fascist state?"
- cazum 8y agoI think you mean authoritarian state. Fascism is a specific right wing thing.
- burfog 8y agoNo, and until a decade ago there wasn't anybody trying to push that falsehood. Fascism involves heavy government control of everything. "All within the state, nothing outside the state, nothing against the state." -- Benito Mussolini That is anything but right wing.
- dragonwriter 8y agoIt's absolutely right-wing. It's not libertarian, but libertarian isn't equal to right-wing; you can have right-libertarians, but even the most extreme of those is more moderately right (and within the wide classical liberal tradition) than fascists, who are essentially—while certainly there was some novelty involved in Mussolini's time—a conscious throwback further right to classical conservatism.
- burfog 8y agoLibertarian isn't equal to right-wing, but neither is nationalism or racism or anything else that you may see in fascism. Fundamentally, the left is about collectivism and the right is about individualism. The difference is whether you think the state is a provider or a parasite. It's about wanting the government to take care of you or get out of your way. It's about wanting the government to make everybody have equal stuff or an equal opportunity.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Fundamentally, the left is about collectivism and the right is about individualism. No, its not. That's pretty much the libertarian-authoritarian axis, which is largely orthogonal to the left-right axis. Libertarian socialism is not only a thing, it's an older thing than modern, pro-capitalist right-libertarianism. (It's also older than Leninism.)
- burfog 8y agoSo what exactly is left-right in your mind? It's looking like you don't think Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren are on the left, and you don't think Rand Paul and Clarence Thomas are on the right. Perhaps you are calibrated to a non-US definition. If so, you should qualify it as something like "UK right" or "UK left" or whatever.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> It's looking like you don't think Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren are on the left Relative to the center in the US they are on the left and also, if not on the authoritarian side, at least not on the libertarian side either. > and you don't think Rand Paul and Clarence Thomas are on the right. Paul is, rhetorically at least, a right-libertarian. Thomas is a partisan Republican who is quiet enough on ideological issues that I wouldn't try to place him other than somewhere vaguely on the right. > Perhaps you are calibrated to a non-US definition. No, actually, my degree is focussed on the US political space, not that it really matters (the US center is way to the right of the developed world, such that what is by broader standards a center-right faction has recently been dominant in the left-most of the two major parties, but that just affects position on that axis, not what the axes are; it's also true that US politics seems unidimensional due to the two party system, so all variations often get characterized as left-right even when they aren't and only weakly, if at all, correlate with left-right variation.)
- Udik 8y agoHow different is that from public companies with large funds- for example pension funds- as shareholders? Even if the property is public, the objective of maximizing profit doesn't change, and that is obtained by appointing ceos and managers.
- PeterisP 8y agoFrankly, those two things are more similar than they might look. I mean, what's the practical difference between owning 0.00000001% of the nation's productive assets versus getting paid 0.00000001% of GDP as UBI? One aspect is that ownership might be alienable (i.e. you can sell that basic asset), but a system like that would be just a short-term bandaid since we'd expect that within a few decades we'd have millions of people who own nothing, and then we'd back to square one. But if it can't be sold, then ownership of productive assets is pretty much the same thing as getting dividends from those assets, and that is pretty much the same thing as unconditional income, perhaps with a slightly different calculation rules on how it changes year by year.