3 ms·
A talk by the Throwing Rocks as the Google Bus author. A little muddled but I think his argument is the problem UBI is "it's just a way of perpetuating our role
by tim333 8y ago
A talk by the Throwing Rocks as the Google Bus author. A little muddled but I think his argument is the problem UBI is "it's just a way of perpetuating our roles as consumers at the bottom of the pyramid not as owners" while I guess the 0.1% still own everything.
Which I guess could be an issue although as we don't have UBI who knows how it'd play out.
- devoply 8y agoThat's obviously how it would play out. The way it works right now is that corporations for the work that you do for them give you money which you use to buy goods from them. UBI makes it so that the government taxes corporations and gives money to consumers to buy things from them. How much money is entirely political but you can be assured that there will always be more need for growth and that consumers will always be told to tighten their belts. You will also never have enough money left over to invest or save a nest egg. So over time more income share will go to the top.
- tim333 8y agoThe other main way for it to play out would be to vote in some left wing style wealth redistribution. That kind of thing does happen. Maybe not just now but if Google and Amazon's AGI robots were taking over everything I could see a vote in that direction.
- tim333 8y agoLooking that up I don't think redistributive tax has to be left wing. Top income tax rates were 90%+ under Winston Churchill (Cons) and Eisenhower (Rep).
- PeterisP 8y agoI'd think of it not as a way for "perpetuating our roles as consumers at the bottom of the pyramid not as owners" but as acknowledging that the large picture is changing from a loop where nearly everyone is both a consumer a producer to an environment where large portion of people will inevitably be only consumers, because the economy won't need their labor anymore. And it's reasonable to assume that these people - who have little economic power now, and will have less and less of it - won't magically become the owners of the world. They might seize ownership with force in a revolution or they may get handed that ownership as a handout, but they can not trade for it or work for it or bargain for it, they don't have and won't have anything to offer to those who currently own the world's resources and means of production. It's not a way of perpetuating the current roles, it's a way of treating the consequences of current roles so that the consequences are more humane. Of course, one may argue that keeping the consequences horrific is more likely to motivate radical change, which is true, but IMHO not a good way to proceed.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> A little muddled but I think his argument is the problem UBI is "it's just a way of perpetuating our roles as consumers at the bottom of the pyramid not as owners" while I guess the 0.1% still own everything. A UBI funded by a tax on capital income and/or wealth could equally well be construed as enshrining the role of the public as owners, representing a rent charged on capitalists who are mere fee simple property owners by the people, who are the sovereign owners.