3 ms·
> This cripples the economy overall. It prevents San Fran from growing even faster than it already is, but it's not going backwards or anything. NIMBY is a sep
by crazygringo 8y ago
> This cripples the economy overall.
It prevents San Fran from growing even faster than it already is, but it's not going backwards or anything. NIMBY is a separate problem.
> but you can't buy goods and services with nice streets, better coffee, and shorter commutes
That's turning it backwards. That's like saying you can't buy clothes with food or vice-versa. The streets, coffee and commutes already are the goods and services which people, on the whole, desire (even if some individuals don't).
Complaining that money is in the hands of landlords is no different from complaining it's in the hands of Starbucks shareholders. Money doesn't disappear... when landlords receive higher rent, that money is either being re-invested or spent on "real, useful products" in the end.
- rcpt 8y agoIt cripples the economy overall. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/06/opinion/housing-regulations-us-economy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/06/opinion/housing-regulatio...
- crazygringo 8y agoIt means the economy doesn't grow as fast as it would otherwise. But again, it's not shrinking, or remaining stagnant. If you call that "crippling" then keeping Central Park in Manhattan also cripples the economy, by preventing the economic growth that would result in replacing it with hundreds of blocks of offices and apartments. Democratic communities are allowed to choose to slow down economic growth in order to preserve a more liveable physical environment. Do you think preserving Central Park cripples the economy overall?
- camelNotation 8y ago> when landlords receive higher rent, that money is either being re-invested or spent on "real, useful products" in the end. This is simply untrue. Wealthy people do not eventually hit zero on their balance sheets, they typically keep the wealth, invest it by gambling in the market, and pass it on to their children who also do not spend it all. Spending is the key to economic growth and wealthy people absolutely do not spend as much as poorer people on real goods. The economy is always better off with wider distribution of wealth.
- smallgovt 8y agoCan you expand on this? Wealthy people may not hit zero on their balance sheets, but isn't investing their capital in corporations a form of spending? That is, it enables the corporation to make capital expenditures to produce goods and services that will in turn be purchased. As long as wealthy people continue investing their capital, it should be healthy for the economy?
- camelNotation 8y agoYes, there is a balance that has to be struck between how much of your economy is investment and how much is spending on real goods because they are symbiotic. The problem is that when inequality rises too high, you end up with too much money being invested and those investment returns either slowing down or being artificially accelerated by gaming the market other ways (think the 2008 collapse).
- crazygringo 8y ago> they typically keep the wealth By investing it. And even the small proportion being kept as cash in the bank is invested by the bank. > invest it by gambling in the market If they're investing well, then they're directing that capital to productive uses, helping to produce goods that people buy. If they're investing badly by "gambling" then they will quickly lose their money to good investors who will direct it to productive uses, producing goods that people buy. > and pass it on to their children Regardless of your views on an inheritence tax (I personally favor it), what is not spent will continue to be invested, and the same arguments above apply. This is all just Econ 101.
- camelNotation 8y agoIf every single dollar in the economy is invested and nothing is spent on real products, it's fake money and will inevitably collapse. Investment is not wrong in itself, but investment that is out of balance with spending on real goods is crippling because the real goods are where the rubber meets the road on investment returns. That is what happens when only a few people have all the cash and the rest are just barely getting by. You aren't maximizing growth and, as a consequence, your nation will lose power in the global market.