5 ms·
So much time oxygen is burned trying to get San Franciscans to change their ways. Why don't businesses shop around for cities more? Make it in the city's incent
by legitster 8y ago
So much time oxygen is burned trying to get San Franciscans to change their ways. Why don't businesses shop around for cities more? Make it in the city's incentive to solve these problems? Why does San Francisco deserve a monopoly on high paying tech jobs? It is pretty clear that nothing is getting done because no one is worried about the big businesses moving away?
- kortilla 8y agoTech jobs have little to do with SFs housing problem, tech is just a convenient scapegoat. In the 80s the blame was finance.
- umeshunni 8y agoMeanwhile, every time there's a proposal to increase density and build more housing, the local NIMBYs show up and protest. My neighborhood association just sent us this today: https://m.imgur.com/gallery/TvX3679 https://m.imgur.com/gallery/TvX3679
- rayiner 8y agoSan Francisco sounds like such a hellscape. Apparently, most of the city is zoned with a 40-foot height limit: https://qpho.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5843aebefa7517e39d3b4bd6fc1f6a99.webp https://qpho.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5843aebefa7517e39d3b4.... That's about the same as the height limit in our neighborhood in exurban Maryland.
- kradroy 8y agoThe buildings might get 2 stories taller! At least they chose a reasonable time for the meeting. I don't know what to do in SF other than trying another round of electing supervisors at large. The way the "supervisorial courtesy" works in the city turns neighborhoods into inviolable fiefdoms. I can influence my supervisor, but my district isn't going to be able to solve the various urban decay problems on its own.
- bduerst 8y agoJoin the progressives fighting this FUD: https://www.sfyimby.org/ https://www.sfyimby.org/
- gridlockd 8y ago> Tech jobs have little to do with SFs housing problem, tech is just a convenient scapegoat. You say that without giving an alternative explanation. If it's not the tech jobs (and the jobs built around them) that raised demand so much, what else is it? > In the 80s the blame was finance. Again, why do you assume that finance was just the scapegoat, not the actual reason?
- ghobs91 8y agoOutside of having top notch universities, the biggest indicator of a city's ability to have a big tech industry is the size of the VC community. VCs are largely already wealthy, and SF is a pleasant city to live in if you're already wealthy. As such, they have little incentive to move, and so founders will continue to flock there to start their companies. I completely agree that shopping around for cities should be easier, so that city governments like SF are forced to get their head out of their ass and make their city competitive. However, until SF becomes unpleasant to live in for rich people, not much is going to change.
- selectodude 8y agoThere is nowhere on earth that can't be made pleasant to live if you have enough money to do it. More to the point, I'm always confused how VCs actively encourage pissing away their own money on somebody else's rent. Sure, spend your own scratch on an $8 million 1000sqft half-lot house, but why not actively encourage others to make your money go farther.
- ghobs91 8y agoGreat point, something I've wondered myself. You'd think with the immense amount of money and influence tech companies and VCs wield, they'd do more to out-lobby the NIMBY homeowners and get denser housing approved.
- gridlockd 8y agoRent is just another overhead. What good is it to save 50% on investment by moving to the middle of nowhere when you can't readily hire anybody? Sure enough, other cities are up and coming, but it takes time.
- selectodude 8y agoYou don't even need to move to the middle of nowhere. Basically anywhere else would work. Even San Diego is rather substantially cheaper than the SF bay and the weather there is orders of magnitude better.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ericabiz 8y ago> Why don't businesses shop around for cities more? They do. Amazon's HQ2 search was the most public of these, but other companies are expanding as well. Apple, without much fanfare, announced a gigantic second campus in Austin, as well as locations in several other cities: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/12/apple-to-build-new-campus-in-austin-and-add-jobs-across-the-us/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/12/apple-to-build-new-ca... Last month, Google announced the lease of a 35-story tower in downtown Austin for up to 5,000 employees: https://www.statesman.com/news/20190131/source-google-to-occupy-35-story-office-tower-in-downtown-austin https://www.statesman.com/news/20190131/source-google-to-occ... Facebook announced the lease of a 17-story tower in north Austin last September: https://www.statesman.com/business/20180906/sources-facebook-to-lease-entire-17-story-tower-at-austins-domain/1 https://www.statesman.com/business/20180906/sources-facebook... These are just Austin (since I live in Austin, I'm familiar with these stories) and just 3 big tech companies. Other tech companies are also expanding in other cities. The cost of living has gotten so out of control in the SF Bay Area that these companies can no longer hire and retain good engineers. Also, it took more than 20 years to change this opinion, but companies are finally starting to embrace remote work and remote workers. There's now a popular trend starting too, where founders live in the Bay Area long enough to get a demo off the ground and raise capital, then leave for greener (cheaper) pastures: https://www.axios.com/entrepreneurs-leaving-bay-area-for-next-startup-9206b98e-a583-4fff-ad03-101dba301e09.html https://www.axios.com/entrepreneurs-leaving-bay-area-for-nex... Unless California can un-gridlock its housing, I expect this trend will only continue.
- gridlockd 8y ago> Austin +1
- bilbo0s 8y agoThey go to Austin though, because they have to be in Austin. Not because they want to spend that money. Same with NYC and NoVA, you just have to be there, they don't want to make outlays to move to NYC. They'd all prefer to just stay in the Bay Area/Si Valley region if they could. Notice, none of them are moving any important people to places like St Louis, or Omaha, or Little Rock, or wherever. Those places are much less expensive than Austin or NoVA, but the tech companies don't really have to be there.
- mark212 8y agoIt’s not just SF. This article also talks about NYC and the massive problem they’re having with the subways. San Diego (#8 in most populous cities) is having a very difficult problem with homelessness and has extremely high rents, one of the least affordable in the US. NIMBY and high rent isn’t just an SF problem, as this article notes. It’s just easier to focus on SF because its problems are well-documented.
- lmm 8y agoEvery dense city has the same problem. Short of creating a company town 2.0, as soon as the population and density are high enough to work for a knowledge employer, the same NIMBY dynamic takes over.
- darksaints 8y agoThis question is practically as old as time. Politicians have been trying to relocate labor and industry for centuries now. Ideas have been proposed and tried, and every place that has been successful has a hundred different competing explanations for why it was successful, and the same goes for the places that were unsuccessful. The matter is complex enough, and success rate low enough, to be able to confidently say we don't know really how to do it. It actually is easier to reform cities than it is to relocate everybody that is made worse off by their poor decisions. And since San Francisco's poor decisions are negatively affecting every city within a 100mi radius, it would make sense for the state intervention to be the tool that brings the change.
- robbrit 8y agoThey are expanding outside SF. Amazon's HQ seems to have deliberately avoided SF; Google has expanded significantly in Austin, Boulder, NYC. Uber has expanded significantly in Pittsburgh. The challenge is that remote offices are difficult to work with. Logistical difficulties like time zones and remote conferencing aside, often you get an all-you-see-is-all-there-is effect from senior management who tend to bias towards the area they are in vs. remote offices which encourages the most ambitious people to relocate back to the mother ship. This then trickles down the corporate ladder - the remote offices will have less exciting or visible projects, so employees there have lower chances at promotion, which provides an incentive for them to move too. It's not a question of companies opening remote offices, it's how they can reduce the effect of gravity that pulls employees back. Gravity aside, the problems described in the article also exist in these other cities too. I'm living in Boulder right now and the NIMBYism is strong here too - I definitely would not be able to afford a house in the city itself.