4 ms·
What's the alternative?
by k__ 8y ago
What's the alternative?
- jseliger 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16704501 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16704501
- b1r6 8y agoTo aggressively build housing. But this requires local politics to cordially ignore the calls to keep the status-quo. In many places, it isn't possible. :/
- crdoconnor 8y agoRaising LVT proxies (e.g. property tax) would make the NIMBYs quieten. Untaxed land -> higher property values -> NIMBYs start getting agitated about proposed housing developments taking chunks out of their home equity by increasing supply
- legitster 8y agoZoning enough housing to meet demand.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThere is technically a second option - better transit to handle it but it is usually a worse one and like landfills they have to be built somewhere. And of course the most efficient, scaleable, and clean transit benefit from higher density housing. And of course people resist that as well. The problem with rent isn't that we don't have a cure but that people don't want to take their medicine.
- sixo 8y agoThe implication of that framing is to somehow overcome: "Local political culture limits natural housing supply growth" via - ignoring NIMBYs or at least reducing their influence, rezoning for density, deregulating to allow smaller/denser/cheaper constructions...
- lern_too_spel 8y agoRent subsidies. https://www.harris.senate.gov/news/press-releases/amid-rising-costs-of-housing-harris-introduces-bill-to-provide-rent-relief https://www.harris.senate.gov/news/press-releases/amid-risin...
- dredmorbius 8y agoBy the same logic as how LVT decreases rents, subsidies are simply a net economic transfer to landlords. They might be a reasonable very short-term emergency measure for a few, but long-term, this exacerbates the problem.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoWrong. Long term, subsidies encourage building more housing. Rent control has the opposite effect. On top of that, subsidies can be directed to bring the most benefit to the city (teachers, for example), while rent control benefits whoever happens to be renting at the time it is instituted. There are better long term options, but the political reasons for rent control are because the short term problems can't be ignored, so they aren't actual alternatives to rent control.
- dredmorbius 8y agoSubsidies encourage more housing as much as any other demand-increase does, which is to say, not at all, where supply is effectively constrained. Existing actors in the landlord, real estate, and finance markets all benefit from constrained supply and price inflation. See: https://web.archive.org/web/20190115035057/https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/eDscpi6Kg7L https://web.archive.org/web/20190115035057/https://plus.goog... You've got to break that logjam, and LVT is one of the most effective ways to do that. Remember: they're not making any more land. You can build out (sprawl, congestion) or up (density). Low land taxes or high improvements taxes both discourage density and encourage sprawl. You cannot change land-use by adjusting demand parameters, long-term and large-scale, only supply and holding costs. Land value tax.
- mises 8y agoI like the approach Houston has taken: no zoning. Many say it won't work, but it does. HOAs pop up in some places if they really don't want commercial.
- throwawaysea 8y agoOK, but isn't the existence of zoning basically the same as the existence of HOAs, in that people have chosen to enact these policies locally, much as HOAs enact hyper-local policies? You seem to be OK with HOAs but not zoning laws, so my question is why are zoning laws bad when it is the choice of their residents (through representative democracy) that they enact policies that preserve their area's character and quality of life?
- mises 8y agoBasically, HOAs are smaller scale. Also, there's a big difference between a bureaucratic gov't doing it and a bunch of residents doing it. Here's the thing about zoning: the people on whom it is enacted probably have a part of one vote in the city council. The decisions are mostly made by the rest of the city. This is especially true in a city as large as Houston. It's the classic problem of tyranny of the majority, which is best solved through hyper-locality (i.e. HOAs).
- throwawaysea 8y agoI disagree with the framing of this as 'tyranny of the majority'. The size of the group of people which is allowed to enact policies is entirely arbitrary, and I don't see a principled reason as to why HOAs would be OK but cities would not. I feel those who are OK with HOAs but against city-level policy-making that constrains growth are likely just drawing the line in a way that matches their own interests or ideologies. I also don't understand why you are framing government as inherently bureaucratic as part of this argument. If that's the case and it justifies not having policy-making left to public governments, why not apply the same logic wholesale and say that we don't need city- or state-level governments at all?
- sisu2019 8y agoDo nothing and let the market sort it out. It's time to try some actual laissez fair now that intervention has failed, as was predicted by most economists. Minimal zoning, minimal taxes, minimal codes. Just boil it down to the raw essentials and give a legal guarantee that every building permit application will be processed in 6 weeks and furthermore legally guarantee that for new buildings all of these new rules are immutable or 10 to 20 years.
- dredmorbius 8y agoLand value tax.
- aglavine 8y agoThe alternative is: Make towns growth into cities. A lot of heartland available. A lot of people wants to own their house. Good Mortgages. Good construction credits. Industries can have tax benefits to be there.