3 ms·
Thanks! You're right that I'm not attempting to in the post, so no worries. > If you control the monetization strictly, it's not open source, and it loses the
by steveklabnik 8y ago
Thanks! You're right that I'm not attempting to in the post, so no worries.
> If you control the monetization strictly, it's not open source, and it loses the appeal.
Hmm, open source and free software both say nothing about money. Could you elaborate a bit?
> Simply having source available isn't appealing to me. Contributing to a project like that is just free labor. I see few mutual benefits.
I think you'll like my next post. :)
> P.S.: Steve, I'm really curious about that Gender bit. Are you going to clarify your thoughts on that?
What I will say is that the speculation of this as being about "brogrammers" is incorrect. I don't want to super get into it, because my thoughts aren't fully formed, and this is a hot-button topic. What I will say is that, in the last 20 years, our discipline has grown, and women are returning to it. If you take the large public figures in both movements, like RMS and esr, both have attitudes and beliefs that are... not great, on topics like sex, gender, and other social issues. In general, the social stuff around these movements is very masculine, and often socially regressive. This makes it hard for women to care about these movements. Obviously, these are mostly broad generalizations, and there have been some women who are involved here. I know several women who are very passionate about both Open Source and Free Software. But I've also spoken to many who say "never", and the numbers speak for themselves.
- 0815test 8y ago> In general, the social stuff around these movements is very masculine, and often socially regressive. This makes it hard for women to care about these movements. You are describing "techbro" culture, but the FLOSS hacker culture which RMS/ESR subscribe to has always been quite different. Hackers' social beliefs are far from unified, but it would not be wrong to describe them as resolutely anti-authoritarian. And their pioneering use of networked communication channels (sometimes even doing away with easily-visible real names, and preferring pseudonymous handles) has definitely helped foster an attitude of gender-equity. Of course, hackers - like anyone else, really - have had to deal with the fact that very few women are in technical professions in the first place. But it would be quite wrong to place the blame for this underlying social fact on the FLOSS community itself!
- steveklabnik 8y agoI agree that the FLOSS culture and the techbro culture are distinct. However, they both have a misogyny problem. Being anti-authoritarian does not mean that you automatically have great gender politics. (And, there can be fundamental disagreements about what "anti-authoritarian" means. I think esr thinks he's anti-authoritarian, but to me, he's quite authoritarian.)
- jchw 8y ago>Hmm, open source and free software both say nothing about money. Could you elaborate a bit? To me, the fact that they say nothing is the important part, and it's why the whole thing works. At first I thought it was weird that GPL didn't limit commercial use, and now I think it was absolutely essential that it didn't. >... If you take the large public figures in both movements, like RMS and esr, both have attitudes and beliefs that are... not great, on topics like sex, gender, and other social issues. ... Interesting. Well, I don't personally see the connection just yet but I'll keep an open mind. It seems like there probably is something to be said.
- steveklabnik 8y ago> To me, the fact that they say nothing is the important part, and it's why the whole thing works. Ah, gotcha. :) Thanks.