6 ms·
Why is this kind of scum still allowed to exist? Every single thing that nasty company does is shady in some way or another. At this point it's not about honest
by Nextgrid 8y ago
Why is this kind of scum still allowed to exist? Every single thing that nasty company does is shady in some way or another. At this point it's not about honest mistakes or "we didn't know" - these guys are blatantly fighting the law in order to continue being shady (it's not about reducing their punishment for past crimes, it's trying to change the law in order to continue to commit crime). Most of society would consider it scandalous and offensive if a convicted murderer was trying to change the law to make murder legal, so why is this cancerous company given a pass?
- return0 8y ago> Why is this kind of scum still allowed to exist because it feeds many a lot of the people in here
- cal5k 8y agoHow many Belgians use Facebook, Instagram or WhatsApp? I believe that’s your answer.
- mikeq101101 8y ago>these guys are blatantly fighting the law in order to continue being shady As much as I hate Facebook, your initial assumption is wrong. The fact that the state deeds something illegal doesn't mean it's wrong, and vice versa. The state is a terrible arbiter of morality.
- falcolas 8y agoWho else do we, the people, have to enforce our rights on our behalf if not the state? It's not as if we can count on Facebook (or any other major corporation) to stand up for our rights in the face of extracting even more money out of our personal data. We need the might of the state to fight back against these entities.
- philipov 8y agoIn Islamic societies, the tyranny of the state is supposed to be checked by the power of religion. Unfortunately, we can all see how well that's going!
- fouc 8y agoMost people would prefer to NOT be tracked, and would consider tracking to be immoral (a privacy violation). Tracking is like having a stalker. Even if the stalker never does anything with your lifestyle habits, routines, preferences, etc, no one would consider that data to be moral for any individual to hold (and by extension any company). The only reason we balk at thinking of tracking as immoral is because it's hugely unrealistic to combat it and outlaw it. And also because companies benefit enormously from it.
- s3cur3 8y ago> Most people . . . Citation needed? If we’re just swapping anecdotes, my experience has been that the vast majority of people I talk to are fine with being tracked on the internet, and think it’s a reasonable exchange for what they get out of it. Is there survey data, for instance, that shows people actually feel strongly about this? Edited to add: I think the most relevant survey data is people voting with their feet. And despite the 24-hour news cycle of Facebook privacy SNAFUs (both intentional and not), their user numbers aren't really falling off. It's hard to take people seriously when they say "what Facebook does is profoundly evil, but it's outweighed by the value of cat videos/Crossfit videos/Tasty recipes/reading the political rants of acquaintances I haven't spoken to in a decade." :/
- mirimir 8y agoIn my experience, that's only the case because they have no bloody clue about how much they're being tracked. Also, from 2012-2013: Study Finds Broad Wariness Over Online Tracking: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/08/technology/most-americans-are-wary-of-being-tracked-online-study-says.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/08/technology/most-americans... Survey: 3 Out Of 4 Consumers Now Notice Retargeted Ads: https://marketingland.com/3-out-4-consumers-notice-retargeted-ads-67813 https://marketingland.com/3-out-4-consumers-notice-retargete...
- fouc 8y agoI've seen that "tracking in exchange for free service" notion around HN a bit before, it sort of makes sense. But what about the case when you're paying for everything and still getting tracked? I think most people expect tracking by the website that they're on, and ONLY that website. That's mainly for improving the website experience and so on. It wouldn't be a privacy violation since it's only their behavior for that website specifically, and no behavior from the other websites. So in reality we're talking about websites that allow third party tracking or sell tracking information to third parties. That's a privacy violation.
- ardy42 8y ago> The fact that the state deeds something illegal doesn't mean it's wrong, and vice versa. The state is a terrible arbiter of morality. It's far better at it than a corporation focused on chasing "shareholder value."
- phatfish 8y agoWho is the arbiter then? The black box of "the markets" or corporations? In a democracy you get the state you vote for. The state has far more right that any other institution to dictate morality.
- mikeq101101 8y ago>In a democracy you get the state you vote for. That is a lie. I didn't vote for the current state, and neither did majority of citizens.
- Frondo 8y agoThe US has a number of explicitly anti-democratic institutions (the electoral college, the senate) that almost certainly wouldn't be devised if you were starting fresh. I mean, can you imagine proposing tomorrow, "in rural parts of the country, let's give people 3x the voting power of those in urban parts of the country"? And yet, here we are.
- sd8f9iu 8y agoWhere does OP imply the state is an arbiter of morality? OP does not say "fighting the law is shady," they say "these guys are blatantly fighting the law in order to continue being shady." The assumption here is that the practice Facebook is fighting to preserve is shady.
- shivo 8y agoIn this case at least the government isn't tracking you and selling the data to third parties. They can claim moral high ground.
- AriaMinaei 8y agoThe anti Facebook wave has outlasted media hype cycles. It seems to be here to stay. Good. I think good things will come out of this.
- gyaniv 8y agoI wish I could be as optimistic as you are. I think Facebooks reach is just to big to actually force it to become good. Sure, you might make it change certain practices, but at the end of the day, they would still find 'problematic' ways to develop their business. Other, similar companies as well (did someone say Google?)
- jerf 8y agoWe tend to overestimate change in the short term and underestimate it in the long term. It's true that it'll probably take longer than we may like to resolve this situation, but in the end it'll probably be resolved more thoroughly and strongly than you'd have guessed. As it is, even just where we are with the HN gestalt's opinion would have been difficult to imagine two years ago. It's slow, but it's a very strong opinion change. Another couple of years and having Facebook on your resume may be a problem getting your next job, who knows.
- existencebox 8y agoWhile I agree with your over/underestimate statement, I unfortunately think you've got it backwards, where we're overestimating the change this pressure is going to lever on how our data is utilized in the short term, and underestimating the reversion to the mean. Next to companies like Palantir, AT&T(Room641A), Equifax, and hell, even credit card processors, I've always found the ire directed at Facebook to seem... scapegoatey? I'd observe that anger against those companies was quick to fade, and has not seemed to negatively impact employees to work for them, nor created a regulatory environment wherein that work isn't supported. (selfishly us-centric here) Hell, after the snowden revelations, did those with NSA/govt credentials have trouble getting a job? If that didn't move the needle (and I say this as someone who had been doing gov. funded research at the time, and would have liked to see a stronger response) I'm pessimistic that we'll ever see meaningful long term perceptual shifts in this respect outside of when they're driven by a media-cycle furor. (To address the root of this comment tree, I think the fad hasn't outlasted the media cycle, I think the media cycle has realized this topic continues to drive clicks for now) Simply, I worry a lack of privacy, and lack of accountability for corporations/govt, has largely become normalized; or at least that people are increasingly unlikely to act in this direction without heavy media pressure. I hope I'm wrong.
- piokoch 8y agoI don't know to what extent the movie "Social Network" is based on facts, but if it is a true picture of Mark Zuckerberg, then that's what is happening is not a surprise. He cheated guys who employed him (to create social network), then he cheated his best friend (from what that remember they all sued him and he had to pay them undisclosed amount of money). What can we expect from someone who looks like someone very greedy without any sense of morals? We should be rather happy he didn't become mass murderer or politician.
- Taylor_OD 8y ago> We should be rather happy he didn't become mass murderer or politician. Yet... I don't think a presidential campaign is out of the question for Zuck at some point in the future.
- mattkevan 8y agoHe also had zero compunction hacking the email accounts of Harvard student newspaper journalists back in the day [0]. Is it any surprise Facebook is what it is today? [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/how-mark-zuckerberg-hacked-into-the-harvard-crimson-2010-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/how-mark-zuckerberg-hacked-i... Interestingly, he did it by recording failed sign-in attempts, seeing if any of the journalists appeared in the logs, then trying the passwords out on their email accounts. Maybe Facebook's recently-announced log of 600m+ passwords was a feature not a bug...
- saluki 8y agoy, the social network is a great movie. Even if it isn't 100% accurate it's an amazing story and fun to watch. The recording failed sign ins to harvest the journalist's passwords always intrigued me. It does make you think when you see they are recently logging passwords.
- JadeNB 8y ago> I don't know to what extent the movie "Social Network" is based on facts, but if it is a true picture of Mark Zuckerberg, then that's what is happening is not a surprise. If your only information to support your post is a fictionalised movie, then maybe it's appropriate to wait to make your post until you can gather more information.
- Brain_Thief 8y agoThis type of behavior is exactly why I block all online ads, always. The fact that large companies like Google and Facebook (and many others) not only go out of their way to deceive their users about what they actually do with their data, but actually actively lobby relevant governments to prevent any kind of privacy protections from being enacted, is all the evidence I need to understand that their operations are fundamentally at odds with the concept of personal privacy and freedom. There is an argument that is often made when I (or others) advocate for ad blocking, and it always involves the evocation of "the little guy" content creator / website owner who gets shafted when adblockers are used. The problem with this argument, and the reason that I feel fully justified - even obligated - to blanket block all ads, is that it is essential to exert SOME kind of pressure against the large surveillance companies. They clearly don't care about their user's preferences, so the next way to fight this trend is to erode, to the greatest extent possible, the economics of their operations. Facebook and the rest of the surveillance corporations can create shadow profiles on me from my digital crumbs if they want. At the end of the day I cannot stop them from doing that - and that's why I will never view, click on, or interact with any online ad under any circumstances, to ensure that they don't reap any significant economic reward from stalking me. When / if a semblance of sanity returns to online advertising and the personal privacy rights of users are respected by default, I will change my behavior accordingly so that content creators are supported. In the mean time I directly donate where possible. On a side note, I notice an obliquely similar situation with Comcast and other big, anti-consumer tech companies that cannot avoid having large customer-facing communications divisions. The people they have manning their phone systems are inevitably exhausted, desperate-sounding, and clearly under some sort of sales quota. Sometimes I almost think that Comcast intentionally makes the lives of their call center employees as miserable as possible so that customers feel guilty dealing with them on the phone and have a lower probability of complaining about the company - after all, why beat up the peon in the cubicle farm about working for a company they already hate? It's almost as if these big companies have decided to use regular people's lives as human shields to hide their inhumanity behind.
- dang 8y agoPlease make your points without calling names like this. That's one of the core site guidelines here, and your comment violates it badly. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. Plenty of HN users post criticisms of Facebook (among other things) while remaining substantive and thoughtful. Please be more like them when posting here. It isn't that you owe better to Facebook (or whoever). It's that you owe better to this community. Each comment posted here is responsible for the quality of the discussion that flows out of it.
- Nextgrid 8y agoPoint taken, apologies. Feel free to edit my post.