3 ms·
At first I had typed a paragraph here about how you are wrong, but then I realized that I don't have any numbers on this, nor do I even know a measure on how th
by roel_v 16y ago
At first I had typed a paragraph here about how you are wrong, but then I realized that I don't have any numbers on this, nor do I even know a measure on how this could be quantified. I still think you're wrong, but I can't prove it. Do you have any numbers on the amount of redistribution that happens e.g. from blue to red states in the US? If so, is there a description of the methodology used somewhere? Or does anyone else know of figures or research in this area?
- _grrr 16y agoThe UK spends ~£6 Billion/yr on EU. Total UK Budget is £620 Billion. Sources: UK Budget: http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2010/may/17/uk-public-spending-departments-money-cuts# http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2010/may/17/uk-publi... EU Contributions: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8036096.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8036096.stm Afraid I don't have figures for US.
- roel_v 16y agoThis BBC is a very nice summary, thanks. It looks like it accounts for payments that are not directly to the Member States too, which is the hardest part to account for (I base this on the total payments to France which must include the CAP (agricultural) subsidies). I have only briefly searched for a couple of reference countries, but it seems that about 1% of the state budget contribution to the EU is the 'normal' amount, with the 'net' expenditures (after discounting for income) is only 30% of that at most (for Germany, for the lesser net contributors that number drops exponentially). So that seems very small, certainly less than I had expected. Then again, most the most expensive government jobs (social security, medical insurance, pensions) are governed at Member State level, so maybe it shouldn't be that surprising. So anyway, then we can reduce the original question to 'is there more than 1% income redistribution between states in the US'. Which I think there will be, since Medicaid and SS are federal programs, right? Plus military spending, which redistributes from states without bases or research to states who do have them, and which makes up a big part of the federal budget. Maybe my initial feeling was wrong, and there is much more redistribution between US States than there is between EU Member States. I'd love to spend the rest of my day researching but I'm afraid I don't have time for that ;)