3 ms·
Here is a brief guide to reading patents: * Ignore the title, it will only confuse you. * Ignore the abstract, it will only confuse you. * Ignore the figures
by jcranmer 8y ago
Here is a brief guide to reading patents:
* Ignore the title, it will only confuse you.
* Ignore the abstract, it will only confuse you.
* Ignore the figures, it will only confuse you.
* Ignore the description, it doesn't matter.
* Jump straight to the claims (the only thing left in the patent). This is literally the only thing that matters in the entire document.
* Ignore most of the claims--anything that says "the thing of claim N". You can't violate those without violating other parts of the patent, by definition. The Google patent view helpfully puts these in lighter gray.
* You can also generally go straight only to the first claim, because the other claims end up being subtly-reworded variations of the first claim.
* This claim is, in short, "A thing comprising A, B, and C." You have to have all of A, B, and C to violate the patent. If you have just A and B and no C, you don't violate it. If you have A, B, and something that is similar to C but you used a relay where C says to use a transistor, you don't violate it.
- tyingq 8y agoThe point is that it isn't novel. Novelty is supposed to be a requirement for a patent claim to be patentable. This patent is like making a drink by mixing 4 different fruit juices, but stirring it with a teak spoon. No identical prior art, very specific claims. Not novel.
- sneak 8y agoThe patent office has been granting technology patents for non-novel things for ages, sadly. There does not appear to be any fix for it, as it even ensnares one of the world’s richest companies. Presumably there would need to be consequences to the government for granting non-novel patents, and there appear to be none.
- kurthr 8y agoWell, I kinda agree, but in that case it should be easy for the defendant to find prior art that meets the elements of the claim or to modify their implementation to avoid the teak spoon. That they haven't makes me wonder if they find some novel utility in the teak spoon.
- Angostura 8y agoI for one thank you - I found this a very useful comment