4 ms·
(I'd like to note that most of these thoughts that follow are not directly tied to the article or aimed at Steve Klabnik; the article is good but it doesn't see
by jchw 8y ago
(I'd like to note that most of these thoughts that follow are not directly tied to the article or aimed at Steve Klabnik; the article is good but it doesn't seem to make an assertion about what's right or wrong.)
I still hold strong that this "war" is getting silly. This whole thing seems so antithetical.
Open source is being chosen by developers and startups because it has technical benefits, it's appealing, it attracts attention, etc. The reason why it is all of those things is exactly because of what open source is. If you control the monetization strictly, it's not open source, and it loses the appeal. Simply having source available isn't appealing to me. Contributing to a project like that is just free labor. I see few mutual benefits.
In my personal opinion, SaaS is not exploitation. Being able to do this is the point. The difference today is that there are people releasing software as open source under licenses that permit others to monetize their software... and then are shocked when they actually do it. Last time I made this argument, I mentioned Linux, and being the quintessential open source project it's a super good example of how open source can be collectively beneficial. I stand by this, and I would presume Linus is not bothered by the massive monetization of Linux. Since that's the point.
If someone wants to build proprietary software, please do. The open source community can survive without another NoSQL database, I'm sure, and nobody will blame you. Few will do this, though, because many want to eat their cake and have it too. Whatever. In any case, please don't attempt to conflate "open source" with "shared source" in the meantime. I've said it before and I will say it again: You aren't saving open source. You are saving your profit model. And nobody blames you for that. I say this as a continued user of Caddy, Redis, etc.
Disclaimer: I'm an employee of Google, these are my personal opinions and not those of my employer.
P.S.: Steve, I'm really curious about that Gender bit. Are you going to clarify your thoughts on that?
- 0815test 8y ago> Steve, I'm really curious about that Gender bit. Are you going to clarify your thoughts on that? I'd like to know as well. Most others here have suggested that it's a veiled reference to "techbros" supposedly taking over the FLOSS community in the 2000s and 2010s, but that's both silly and would not represent a change in gender anyway, but rather a shift in broad social attitudes (including those relating to gender) away from the traditional hacker-values of openness and personal autonomy.
- lmm 8y agoThe original point was for users to be able to fix bugs in the software they were using, no? You can frame that as good for ideological reasons (users should have the freedom to solve their own problems), as Free Software does, or good for pragmatic reasons (if users can scratch their own itches then this will result in better software), as Open Source does. But in either case, SaaS undermines it: the user may be able to download a copy of the source and fix the bug that was bothering them, but they still have to live with the bug in the version of the software they're actually using.
- indymike 8y agoThis ultimately becomes incentive for the SaaS provider to do a much better job. The most basic level of SaaS is simply OpenSourceApp as a service where devops, upgrades, security, logging and such just work... We use 5-6 different SaaSified services to deliver our product and honestly, it's fantastic versus maintaining more servers and network infrastructure.
- lmm 8y agoBy that logic there would be no point in open source/free software for non-SaaS software.
- indymike 8y agoNo, it just creates options... in this case, one of them is paying someone to make it work and make it reliable so I can focus on the things that make my product different and special. Regardless, I wouldn't be in business without free and open source software...
- jchw 8y agoThe motivation for Linux was definitely about the inability to fix bugs, but I'm pretty sure the same cannot be said about the motivations and reasoning behind the GPL.
- belorn 8y ago
- steveklabnik 8y agoThanks! You're right that I'm not attempting to in the post, so no worries. > If you control the monetization strictly, it's not open source, and it loses the appeal. Hmm, open source and free software both say nothing about money. Could you elaborate a bit? > Simply having source available isn't appealing to me. Contributing to a project like that is just free labor. I see few mutual benefits. I think you'll like my next post. :) > P.S.: Steve, I'm really curious about that Gender bit. Are you going to clarify your thoughts on that? What I will say is that the speculation of this as being about "brogrammers" is incorrect. I don't want to super get into it, because my thoughts aren't fully formed, and this is a hot-button topic. What I will say is that, in the last 20 years, our discipline has grown, and women are returning to it. If you take the large public figures in both movements, like RMS and esr, both have attitudes and beliefs that are... not great, on topics like sex, gender, and other social issues. In general, the social stuff around these movements is very masculine, and often socially regressive. This makes it hard for women to care about these movements. Obviously, these are mostly broad generalizations, and there have been some women who are involved here. I know several women who are very passionate about both Open Source and Free Software. But I've also spoken to many who say "never", and the numbers speak for themselves.
- 0815test 8y ago> In general, the social stuff around these movements is very masculine, and often socially regressive. This makes it hard for women to care about these movements. You are describing "techbro" culture, but the FLOSS hacker culture which RMS/ESR subscribe to has always been quite different. Hackers' social beliefs are far from unified, but it would not be wrong to describe them as resolutely anti-authoritarian. And their pioneering use of networked communication channels (sometimes even doing away with easily-visible real names, and preferring pseudonymous handles) has definitely helped foster an attitude of gender-equity. Of course, hackers - like anyone else, really - have had to deal with the fact that very few women are in technical professions in the first place. But it would be quite wrong to place the blame for this underlying social fact on the FLOSS community itself!
- steveklabnik 8y ago