6 ms·
Two things most surprising about this: - Presumably you can get 90% of the value for 5% of the price. McDonald's isn't Amazon. They have 100 (?) menu items, no
by crazygringo 8y ago
Two things most surprising about this:
- Presumably you can get 90% of the value for 5% of the price. McDonald's isn't Amazon. They have 100 (?) menu items, not 1,000,000 products. Why are they spending $300M instead of hiring a few data scientists? Or just be a customer of the company?
- Dynamic Yield has many other clients, and it sounds like they'll continue to serve those. Is McDonald's the right owner for a high-tech customer intelligence product? It just feels like such a bizarre cultural and core-competency fit. Maybe invest partly in it, but buy it outright? I don't get it. Seems like you'd rather share the board with other experts?
- tomnipotent 8y agoI think you are drastically underestimating McDonald's - they have 36k+ stores in almost every country on the planet serving 69MM+ customers daily with a brand recognition in line with Apple, Coca Cola, and Nike. They also spend money on advertising across every conceivable channel. Number of SKUs has nothing to do with it (which likely numbers in the many hundreds across the globe considering regional & seasonal specialities). McDonald's has everything to gain by infusing this kind of DNA into their operations.
- badestrand 8y ago> McDonald's has everything to gain by infusing this kind of DNA into their operations. That seems logical but how much will it infuse Machine Learning into McD's DNA if the acquired startup sits in Israel? It seems to me the employees will not even interact much with each other, how can there be much of incorporating thinking, methods or practices?
- tomnipotent 8y ago> It seems to me the employees will not even interact much with each other, how can there be much of incorporating thinking, methods or practices? What does physical proximity have to do with anything? McDonalds does $20B+ in revenues, has 210k direct employees and 1.9M when you include franchises. At this scale, the only people that need to interface is senior management.
- baxtr 8y agoOn a side note: I recently watched "The Founder", which tells the story how Ray Kroc scaled McDonalds. Highly recommended! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_Kroc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_Kroc
- pryelluw 8y agoBook version is so much better: https://www.amazon.com/Grinding-Out-McDonalds-Ray-Kroc/dp/0312929870 https://www.amazon.com/Grinding-Out-McDonalds-Ray-Kroc/dp/03...
- stillsut 8y agoIf you liked the story of Ray Kroc, you'll like the story of Howard Schultz scaling Starbucks; the similarities are spooky.
- mwerty 8y agoAny book recommendations?
- stillsut 8y agoThe first half of Schultz's Pour Your Heart Into It. Even its title, similar to Kroc (his: Grind It Out).
- ewhanley 8y agoNot a book but there’s a good episode of the How I Built This podcast that gives a great overview. https://one.npr.org/?sharedMediaId=551874532:554086519 https://one.npr.org/?sharedMediaId=551874532:554086519
- s3r3nity 8y agoI really enjoyed Schultz's "Onward," which talks about his return as CEO in 2008 to turn around Starbucks, which was struggling mightily at the time. Yes, there was a time when Starbucks was not doing well.
- nl 8y agoHere (Australia) at least you can do custom burger orders on demand, which explodes the SKUs.
- Operyl 8y agoCommon everywhere, they're "grill slips." It's not a new SKU, but a customization to it. Still, wonder how much analytics they pull on that when designing new products.
- tomnipotent 8y agoThis has been the secret for decades in most fast food restaurants to make sure your order is made fresh (by making requests that ensure a pre-cooked item can't be used).
- Operyl 8y agoIt’s also extremely common that a lot of the chains will have a “fuck you” mentality and just reuse an existing burger any way if they know you’re just trying to skirt the freshness. The real pro tip is to just ask nicely for a fresh burger, they’ll do an Ask Me, and everyone is happy. Source: 2 years at a McDonald’s in my younger days. EDIT: That is to say this isn't really a secret, it happens all the time. But when you're working with teenagers working for minimum wage, who hate when others try to be sneaky/talk down on them just being upfront and nicely asking what you want, and being sure to say "I know it'll take a bit longer, that's fine." is better than the alternative.
- bonestamp2 8y agoOn this note, and current McDonald's employees are going to hate me... but if you want fresh, hot and crispy fries, ask for "no salt". They'll have to put a new batch down, clean off the scooper and then give you fresh out of the frier fries. Then ask for a salt packet, because they're shit without salt.
- 8y ago
- throwawayjava 8y ago> Presumably you can get 90% of the value for 5% of the price. McDonald's isn't Amazon. "McDonald's isn't Amazon" seems like a good enough reason. Amazon can "just hire a few PhDs/seasoned engineers", plug them into the right places in the company, and expect good things to happen. McDonald's would need to hire a new team from the leadership down and would be working up-wind in a hot seller's labor market at every level. > They have 100 (?) menu items, not 1,000,000 products. McDonald's is a huge company with lots of opportunities to apply ML. Store operation, hiring, supply chain optimization, menu/product design, lots of resource scheduling problems, marketing, etc. I can easily see McDonald's making back hundreds of millions very quickly just by decreasing the friction and amount of time required to make improvements in these and other areas. > Is McDonald's the right owner for a high-tech customer intelligence product? It just feels like such a bizarre cultural and core-competency fit. Automated ordering is becoming a core part of McDonald's customer experience. Automated and augmented decision making is becoming a core part of McDonald's franchise management. Outsourcing those things would mean putting the fate of the company's future in someone else's hands. Plus, there's huge upside to owning that IP. McDonald's is taking leadership on automating away the sales clerk and decreasing reliance on skilled/knowledgeable franchise owners and managers.
- notyourday 8y ago* What do I want? * You want nothing. * Wrong, I want a burger. * You want a burger * What do I want to drink? * You want a burger * Wrong, I want a coke * You want a coke Two days later. * What do I want for breakfast? * You want a burger and a coke.
- wtvanhest 8y agoYou are vastly underestimating the cost of standing up a data science team. They need data infrastructure, experts in cleaning data, and actual data scientists, support etc. Its a huge under taking.
- _dps 8y agoI know from experience that you can put together a very good full-suite team of 20 people in SFBA with a 5-year budget in the tens of millions. That's a fraction of a $300M acquisition (though obviously the acquisition brings IP, relationships, a team that already works together, etc.) Such a team is on the small side for a Fortune 500, but definitely large enough to do real work and more than pay for themselves (especially if you're introducing serious ML into your company for the first time).
- wtvanhest 8y agoYour budget is not even close for a company as large and complex as MCD. That $300mm is an investment in a reoccuring revenue stream as well. There is a very real possibility that the true org cost is zero for MCD.
- _dps 8y agoMy budget estimate is based on actual experience building data science operations at Fortune 500s.
- pionar 8y agoI don't know about McD's, but I work at another very large franchised quick-service restaurant (QSR) (not McD's, but in a different category). For companies like these, that operate in 10's of thousands of franchisee-owned locations, the number of products and the combination of configurations is not merely a function of the things you see on the menu. It's all of those products, with their different combination of parts (beef patties, lettuce, etc.), and then franchisee and regional variations (In some countries, you can't tell a franchisee what they can or can't sell, etc.) Add on top of that customer modifications to the product in their order (extra pickles, no onions, etc.) Why does this matter? It drives lots of stuff - food costs, inventory, inventory & sales forecasting (how many pickles do I need this week?) new item research, profit margins, etc. So you take this, multiply it by 10,000, 15,000, or, in McD's case, 36,000 stores across 100+ countries (half both those numbers in my company's case) and you're talking about vast amounts of information across millions of transactions every day, and that is in fact Big Data. Whether this is a smart move, I'm not sure. I'm of the opinion that if a piece of technology is core to the _operation_ of your business (for a QSR, things like POS systems, backend administrative systems, etc.), it should be in your house. Other things (HR systems, big data systems) should not be. But maybe McD's sees it differently.
- teddyuk 8y ago>> "and that is in fact Big Data." don't you mean "and that is in fact Big Mac Data."
- hammock 8y agoDomino's has even less menu choice than McDonalds... But you do make a good point. I went into the flagship mcd's in Chicago the other day and those touchscreens, while not tinesaving at all, do allow you to get deep into a big menu and make all kinds of modifications. My friend accidentally ordered a bunless burger. As for me, when it said mcgriddles were sold out/greyed out, I simply ordered a sausage biscuit but subbed mcgriddle for the biscuit (the counter guy later told me they were still sold out and offered me a free mcdouble instead).
- greedo 8y agoMcDonalds uses this type of data in so many ways. When I worked for them, they uncovered a franchisee defrauding them and the IRS. This was when x86 POS systems were first replacing Scantron menu systems. This franchisee hired someone to customize the POS system to underreport sales. This affected both the tax collections, as well as franchise fees due. How was he found? Well, all food/paper sales were through one vendor that reports sales to the mothership. They could see that he was ordering enough supplies for X, while reporting Y sales. He skimmed about 10% extra over two years before they busted him. So for roughly $200K he lost all four franchises, and faced a huge tax issue. This type of data processing across all the McOpCo stores and franchises will be invaluable.
- manojlds 8y agoThe kind of items that McDonalds has in India is very very different from what I have seen in the US. While I agree with your sentiment, you are also vastly underestimating the needs of McDonalds.
- jhayward 8y agoIt's mentioned in the article, but much of what drives McDonald's profitability is their supply chain and logistics, and r&d around food prep/meal production. There are huge dollar volumes there at very low margins and it is an area of great advantage (not only in cost, but in what it's possible to do product-wise) if done well. It's a perfect area for data science / ML type applications.
- anonu 8y agoIt depends how you view McDonald's. If you think it's the biggest employer of burger flippers in the world, then you're probably right... Seems like a weird fit. But if you think of them as experts in agriculture, farming, supply chain and logistics, kitchen automation, marketing, global scale business build out... Then I could see how an acquisition like this could be synergistic. Don't forget that the Trump tax cuts have provided big companies with a windfall. They have way more free cash flow than they did just 2 years ago. So they also are desperate to find new ways to deploy cash.
- PeterisP 8y agoThe world's biggest employer of burger flippers also has a clear economic interest in developing tech that'll be the world's biggest unemployer of burger flippers. McDonalds is heavily investing into automation for the ordering process; and as soon as it becomes technically practical and reliable enough, they're going to want to automate even more.
- nine_k 8y agoAs everybody likely knows, a significant part of McDonald's's revenue is operations with realty, which they have plenty. I wonder what else are they leveraging from their position of a huge company with a truly global presence. I mean, Amazon also sells books as it used to, and selling stuff is their core business, but they are not limited to that.
- ddebernardy 8y agoIt might be something like what FaceBook did with the VPN app that got them into trouble: if they continue to serve the other customers, they get to see their data -- what's trending in the market, etc.