2 ms·
What you say about the guidebook and rounded corners is (afaik, don't actually recall the guidebook part of the case but I do know they won on some other patent
by gpm 8y ago
What you say about the guidebook and rounded corners is (afaik, don't actually recall the guidebook part of the case but I do know they won on some other patents as well) true, but it doesn't change the fact that one of the things Apple did win on was "Apple patented rounded corners".
The patent that literally just consisted of rounded corners, not the rest of the stuff, was upheld as a valid patent and Samsung was found to be infringing it. Theoretically, if Samsung hadn't violated any other Apple IP, the court should still have found them to be infringing the rounded corners patent.
This is worth ridiculing, and outlines the state of the patent system, which clearly needs adjusting.
- Angostura 8y agoIts worth pointing out that this protection was a Design Patent (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_patent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_patent) which despite the name is quite different from a utility patent - it basically allows decorative doohickeys to be protected. Coke's curvy bottle is covered by a design patent, for example.
- Marsymars 8y agoWas covered. Coke's bottle design patents have been expired for close to 70 years or more. I had to look this up, because I figured there was somehow a risk that Coke had managed to get century-long patents in America.
- tooltalk 8y agoNo. design patents only last 15 years. Coke's bottle design I believe is protected under trade dress/mark, which allows Coke's unique design to be protected in perpetuity. https://www.upcounsel.com/trade-dress https://www.upcounsel.com/trade-dress: "When deciding whether to obtain a trade dress trademark, a design patent, or both, you should first consider what each protects: Design patent - protects the design of a product giving you exclusivity over the design for a certain period. Even if you don't manufacture or sell the product, you are still protected by a design patent. Trade dress - protects your investment in marketing and advertising where you have created a particular image for your product, and consumers exclusively associate that image with your product. As design patents and trade dress protect different things, the requirements are different for both: Design patent - the design firstly has to be new and cannot be a variation of a design that already exists. The design must also be ornamental in nature, rather than purely functional. That said, it can have some functionality. Trade dress - a trade dress must be something that is distinctive and connects the consumer to the product, i.e. the consumer instantly recognizes the source of the trade dress. Unlike a design patent, it cannot be functional in any way. Design features that have a function should be protected with a design patent." Do note that all of Apple's 'trade dress' claims were thrown out because of their failure to meet "non-functionality"/ornamental requirement.
- Angostura 8y agoI stand corrected. Thank you.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]