2 ms·
Such evidence is useless, as in the brain-in-a-vat scenario (for example), this evidence could be generated by whatever controls the vat. It may have absolutel
by pmoriarty 8y ago
Such evidence is useless, as in the brain-in-a-vat scenario (for example), this evidence could be generated by whatever controls the vat. It may have absolutely no relation to what's in the external world, and one has no way to get to the external world to verify it. Similar objections could be made based on other possible scenarios.
Furthermore, one's own reasoning capabilities might be compromised. Once again, whatever controls the vat could be making you conclude whatever they want, so whatever the evidence might be, you might be drawing the wrong conclusions from it because your reasoning capability is impaired or subverted.
As for parsimony, that's just a heuristic that's been useful to science in the world of experience (ie. the world of appearances or the phenomenal world, to use Kantian terminology). The external world is under no obligation to conform itself to it, nor to anything else that might come from or to human minds.