3 ms·
Yeah, that's 0.0075%. Versus a ballpark of a 10th engineer getting, say, 0.5%. Even a few rounds of dilution can't explain a drop of two orders of magnitude.
by crazygringo 8y ago
Yeah, that's 0.0075%.
Versus a ballpark of a 10th engineer getting, say, 0.5%.
Even a few rounds of dilution can't explain a drop of two orders of magnitude.
I'm thinking the author either didn't pay attention or care or trusted too much in the initial offer, didn't stay long enough to vest most of it, didn't buy most of their options in the end, or all of the above?
- kolbe 8y agoIf the Lyft founders are entering the IPO with about 3.5% each, then I don't think it's crazy for 10th engineers these days to have less than a basis point.
- askafriend 8y agoThat doesn't tell the whole story. There's a dual class share structure and even with the 7.5%, they retain majority control of the company.
- kolbe 8y agoWhen you're talking about valuing their shares, yes, it does tell the whole story. They cannot transfer their extra voting rights, so if they're ever interested in monetizing their investment, they have to convert to limited voting shares to sell. And all we're talking about here is the monetary payout of working at a startup.
- askafriend 8y ago> And all we're talking about here is the monetary payout of working at a startup Fair, I concede my point based on this premise.
- klmr 8y agoThat’s (substantially) more than I have as #5 at a startup. Truth be told I didn’t pay attention to this when joining because at the time they hadn’t yet set up their EMIs and I was told that negotiating for share options is pointless since their expected value is close to zero. So, if I had insisted I could probably have gotten more. But it’s neither unheard-of, nor even particularly rare from what I’ve heard (in the UK).
- cik 8y agoThis number makes complete sense. I was a 'key employee' once upon a time - in a startup that had just raised f&f, and I received a FULL 2% (unheard of for Canada). Fast forward through the (usual) reality of 6 rounds of dilution, and my 2% was worth less than 0.02%. If the startup went from a $2M valuation to $200M (as it did) then my take would have been $40K. Do with that what you will.
- smallgovt 8y agoIt sounds like your startup was unfortunately an outlier with respect to the level of dilution experienced. 99% dilution over 6 rounds is far from 'usual reality'. More common is 20% dilution per round.
- vkou 8y agoIt was also an outlier, in the sense that it had a valuable exit. You've only got one lifetime to pull the equity slot machine, hoping that the reels come up all sixes.
- eanzenberg 8y ago6 rounds of 20% dilution will get you to 74% total dilution from the initial grant.
- Zephyr314 8y agoWhich in this case nets you >$1M [0] vs the 80k quoted above. This also assumes no retention grants over 6 rounds. [0]: 0.02*0.8^6*$200,000,000 = $1,048,576
- rubicon33 8y agoSomething I am always curious about is, was your company / CEO open and honest with you about how your shares were doing? If you worked somewhere for 5 years, it could be easy to think you're safe but meanwhile the CEO is diluting your equity to fractions of what it originally was? Don't they have to report that to employees?
- icedchai 8y agoDilution isn't all that matters. There's also investor liquidation preferences that can drastically change the outcome.
- kyleblarson 8y agoLiquidation pref for investors with preferred shares.